EDWOP

 

Meant to say...

 

 

Well...I know Kasabian checked this thread but chose not to reply (cuz he was online when I checked the thread).

Most likely in a conversation with his mafia buddies to come up with a strategy.

Okay, so your thought is:

 

1. We lynch the two people you're telling us are scum

2. We leave the third townie anonymous, since they're a power role and their chances are better if they remain unknown

 

Sorry if I'm coming off dense, I'm still getting the hang of this.

Okay, so your thought is:

 

1. We lynch the two people you're telling us are scum

2. We leave the third townie anonymous, since they're a power role and their chances are better if they remain unknown

 

Sorry if I'm coming off dense, I'm still getting the hang of this.

 

1. Yes

2. I will let him roleclaim if he wants but I don't particularly want mafia to have another target.

Okay.

 

Well, if movement pegs EM as scum, that probably means KevinH needs to be looked at, too.

Okay.

 

Well, if movement pegs EM as scum, that probably means KevinH needs to be looked at, too.

 

Why would KevinH needs to be looked at?

Why would KevinH needs to be looked at?

 

It looked to me like EM stepped up for KevinH early on during the first day.

It looked to me like EM stepped up for KevinH early on during the first day.

 

 

I find it curious that you select KevinH but none of the others that bandwagoned the no lynch vote.

KevinH has played the game as he always (mostly) does by voting no lynch.

EM tried to justify his switch to no lynch by using KevinH as a cover.

Considering that the no-lynch order was...No-Lynch (5): KevinH, ccabal86, AKCPLUTO, Chaoshawk, Electric Mango

What about ccabal86, AKCPLUTO, and Chaoshawk?

 

 

If anything...I would think you would be third mafia.

Your vote on EM is a classic distancing vote.

While it was at first random...you never unvoted when it started to get a bit serious.

I find it curious that you select KevinH but none of the others that bandwagoned the no lynch vote.

KevinH has played the game as he always (mostly) does by voting no lynch.

EM tried to justify his switch to no lynch by using KevinH as a cover.

Considering that the no-lynch order was...No-Lynch (5): KevinH, ccabal86, AKCPLUTO, Chaoshawk, Electric Mango

What about ccabal86, AKCPLUTO, and Chaoshawk?

 

None of them tied themselves quite so personally to one of the guys you're fingering.

 

If anything...I would think you would be third mafia.

Your vote on EM is a classic distancing vote.

While it was at first random...you never unvoted when it started to get a bit serious.

 

I didn't see any need to change it because the vote for EM wasn't even close to a majority. In other words, my vote meant as much when things got more serious as it did when I cast it.

 

If I go back and check, I bet I'll find other people who didn't bother changing their joke votes, either.

None of them tied themselves quite so personally to one of the guys you're fingering.

 

 

 

I didn't see any need to change it because the vote for EM wasn't even close to a majority. In other words, my vote meant as much when things got more serious as it did when I cast it.

 

If I go back and check, I bet I'll find other people who didn't bother changing their joke votes, either.

 

 

 

Nerau random voted for Preston.

But he's dead so it doesn't matter.

 

Kaziocore selectively chose among the people that voted no lynch.

Not exactly random.

 

Your vote is the only true random vote.

You didn't even bother to try and justify keeping your vote on EM (like Preston did).

 

I could be way off base...but I don't think so.

Again...this is just my opinion.

 

The rest of the town have their own opinions and it will be up to them to lynch the 3rd mafia (assuming that I will be nightkilled).

Nerau random voted for Preston.

But he's dead so it doesn't matter.

 

Actually, yes it does. You're looking for an explanation, and all I'm saying is that I'm not the only one who did it.

 

You didn't even bother to try and justify keeping your vote on EM (like Preston did).

 

Absolutely correct, because I didn't think a ha-ha vote that amounted to nothing required any justification.

@TED - fair enough. You make some valid arguments. But you're still high on my suspect list.

 

VOTE COUNT

Electric Mango (1): CanucksDynasty

 

Not Voting (9): ccabal86, Kaziocore, Electric Mango, Kasabian, Preston, AKCPLUTO, KevinH, Chaoshawk, Tactical Evil Dan

 

With 10 Alive, 6 is needed to lynch.

Edited February 22, 201115 yr by molestargazer

I stand by my decision that no lynching on day 1 was a good idea, just look at all the information we gained! I believe CD is telling the truth, if not he can be our next lynch target. Unfortunately, if he's townie, there's no way he'll live through the night. IF we have some sort of doctor (which I doubt), now would be a good time to protect him...

 

However, I believe the third townie should remain anonymous, revealing himself at this stage would not be a wise decision.

 

I'm going to vote for EM, but I'm not placing my vote yet. We need a full day of discussion first

Man, this game is almost as bad as Paranoia for making you jump at shadows.

Man, this game is almost as bad as Paranoia for making you jump at shadows.

 

Yes. Yes it is.

I stand by my decision that no lynching on day 1 was a good idea, just look at all the information we gained! I believe CD is telling the truth, if not he can be our next lynch target. Unfortunately, if he's townie, there's no way he'll live through the night. IF we have some sort of doctor (which I doubt), now would be a good time to protect him...

 

However, I believe the third townie should remain anonymous, revealing himself at this stage would not be a wise decision.

 

I'm going to vote for EM, but I'm not placing my vote yet. We need a full day of discussion first

Had you voted with me, we would have lynched mafia on D1. Just saying.

I see you EM. What do you have to say?

 

In other news...Preston was also checking the thread earlier but chose not to comment.

[quote name='CanucksDynasty' date='21 February 2011 - 09:41 AM'

Kasabian and EM moved last night.

Due to my analysis above...they must be mafia.

 

 

I'm not mafia, I'm an insomniac. I don't have special powers, I can't see what is going on at night, all I can do is stay awake because I can't sleep. At first I thought it was some sort of new power role, kinda like a cop. Mole said that I did not have to send in night actions and I expected that by being awake that I would automatically pick up on some night movement but no such luck. I PM'd Mole today because I did not get a night PM that told me anything. He said I wasn't supposed to get one. I thought it was odd that I was up last night but didn't get any info. Now that CD has role claimed he's a security guard it makes sense. Mole made me an insomniac so CD would see me on tape and get suspicious.

 

With this knowledge, we must vote for Kasabian. I'm sure he'll turn up scum if CD is positve the 3rd person on camera is protown.

 

I'm sure Mole would not let CD see 2 out of the 3 mafia on camera on the very first night. That would be way too over powered. So if it's not me, and it's not the 3rd mystery person, it has to be Kasabian.

 

 

Vote: Kasabian

I am certain that the 3rd person is not mafia. Cuz I was told that he was not mafia. He may be an independent 3rd party or a pro-town townie.

 

Interesting idea of an insomniac. So you're saying that your role was to wander around to just mess up my findings?

 

Ummm.....nope. I don't buy it.

Well if you're not going to buy it at least put in a down payment

 

What I'm saying is true, vote for Kasabian and you will see that he is mafia and not me.

 

There is no way that Mole would let you see two mafia on the very first night, that would be waaay too over powered, you know that. Mole made me an insomniac only to mess with your findings and throw a new wrinkle into the game.

 

CD, we've played a lot of games together, help me out on this one. Trust me.

My powers are not as over powered as you think.

 

I only see the movement of people. I do not know their alignment. I'm assuming that the 3rd person (maybe a doc) did something to let me know he was a townie. If he chose someone else to protect, I would have been clueless to his alignment. And it was fortunate that Nerau (the other pro-town power role) was nightkilled since it allowed me to deduce that you and Kasabian are mafia. So you see...a lot of things had to go right to get the info.

You really think Mole would give you a role where you would see two mafia on the first day?

You really think Mole would give you a role where you would see two mafia on the first day?

 

EM...it's quite amusing that you are trying to keep alive.

Just tell me who's the 3rd mafia so we can end the game quicker and start a new one.

 

And given my role description...Yes I believe I could see 2 mafia on the first day.

What part of seeing only movements do you not understand?

 

I could have easily thought that you and Kasa were townies IF Nerau hadn't died, IF the 3rd person did not protect me (I'm assuming a doc protected me).

 

I can only see movements...not alignments.

The way things had unfolded allowed me to deduce that you and Kasa are mafia.

End of story.

 

 

Electric Mango and Kasabian are mafia.

CD, if they're both scum, why does it matter to you which one gets lynched first?

 

Granted, you could make an argument that if EM has scum powers it would stand to reason he'd point the finger at the other guy, but since we don't know either way it doesn't make a difference from the townie perspective -- right?

If that was the case, then why bother to unvote?

 

Because i didnt had any evidence that prove it to me that Ccabal was a scum or not, it was just a random vote, so i decided to unvoted.

 

 

Well...I know Kasabian checked this thread but chose not to reply.

Most likely conversion with his mafia buddies to come up with a strategy.

 

1 mafia most likely did the killing.

1 mafia did something else (like roleblocking or something like that).

1 mafia is probably the leader.

 

The thing to remember is that Nerau was a roleblocker.

Which indicates to me that mafia have more abilities than just killing.

 

So trust me...Kasabian and EM are mafia.

 

We don't know who the 3rd mafia is but the suspect pool will decrease as the game progresses.

 

For example...

 

D2 - 10 players left (7T and 3M)

L2 - EM gets lynch = mafia

N2 - mafia kills me

 

D3 - 8 players left (6T and 2M)

L2 - Kasa gets lynched = mafia

N2 - mafia kills townie

 

D4 - 6 players left (5T and 1M)

Pretty good odds for townie to get it right.

 

Plus we still have 1 more pro-townie power role that can help the town.

 

 

Yea i was checking it earlier, but from my blackberry, internet was to slow to start quoting, or posting something. Wow, that's quiet an imagination you have, "maybe he's talking to his mafia buddies", from where do you get this information from? as far as i know from the game, the scums only talk at nights, this argument he placed on me was to make the other townies think im the mafia, bravo CD. btw correct me if im wrong about this last words.

 

FoS: CanucksDinasty

 

I'm not mafia, I'm an insomniac. I don't have special powers, I can't see what is going on at night, all I can do is stay awake because I can't sleep. At first I thought it was some sort of new power role, kinda like a cop. Mole said that I did not have to send in night actions and I expected that by being awake that I would automatically pick up on some night movement but no such luck. I PM'd Mole today because I did not get a night PM that told me anything. He said I wasn't supposed to get one. I thought it was odd that I was up last night but didn't get any info. Now that CD has role claimed he's a security guard it makes sense. Mole made me an insomniac so CD would see me on tape and get suspicious.

 

With this knowledge, we must vote for Kasabian. I'm sure he'll turn up scum if CD is positve the 3rd person on camera is protown.

 

I'm sure Mole would not let CD see 2 out of the 3 mafia on camera on the very first night. That would be way too over powered. So if it's not me, and it's not the 3rd mystery person, it has to be Kasabian.

 

 

Vote: Kasabian

 

Wow this guy has quite an imagination too, what a great story, just not buying it as well, you wrote that down to dodge the bullet CD placed on you , didn't you? I do give you points for your creativity though, it was expected that you voted against me tbh, as well im voting for you.

 

Vote: Electric Mango

@Kasabian - read all the posts. I'm the Security Guard. That's where I get my info from.