638 replies to this topic

[Alternate_Tree]

I agree that a lynch has to happen, it seems that a mafia majority is getting closer and closer. As to different factions based on color of post, that doesn't follow. It's a new night and so it's more likely that each night will have a different color and that may not have any relevance for factions.

[BeeBs]

Anyway it seems some1 knows about powerful sane/insane ppl and is removing them.

There have only been two nights, I think luck could still be playing a role there. Further, we don't even know (per Kaziocore's post) that we lost a power role last night. Both have indiscriminate names, especially in the land of Kaziocore where flavor reigns, I don't think we should speculate much or we will end up killing ourselves like last game.

I agree that a lynch has to happen, it seems that a mafia majority is getting closer and closer. As to different factions based on color of post, that doesn't follow. It's a new night and so it's more likely that each night will have a different color and that may not have any relevance for factions.

I like the general idea, ie that you're not jumping to that conclusion. However, it seems to me that factions have generally been blocked out on this forum by color. I think you're right on to be skeptical, but I think history would indicate the opposite. If tomorrow we lose another color I'd be more inclined to believe you.

In addition on that point, is it possible a scum was killed last night for some reason? I mean it is a total longshot. But, he is a different color and he appears to be sane. It is pretty ambiguous as to whether he was sane before or after his death. Possibility, yes. However, also very doubtful.

[KevinH]

Townie points:

+1 for not being part of the day 1 lynch attempt on JohnGato
+1 for being active
+1 for getting probed

Most likely to be townie (3 points)

Electric Mango

Probably townie or playing well as scum (2 points)

BeeBs
ccabal86
Eva999
Xx Karl xX

Under scrutiny (1 point)

ABigDeer
Alternate_Tree
Angel Cruz dela Sant
cam177
Daimos
OrangeRush7
Rafay

Most likely to be scum (0 points)

reign of terror

Eva999 gets credit for playing well as scum

+1 point for being the target of Eva999: Rafay
-1 point for defending Nerau/Eva999 on day 1: Cam177
+1 point for being probed again: Electric Mango
+1 point for a plausible role claim: Reign of Terror
-1 point for not bothering to vote at all on day 2: Angel Cruz dela Sant, OrangeRush7, Reign of Terror

Most likely to be townie (4 points)

Electric Mango

Probably townie or playing well as scum (2 points)

BeeBs
Ccabal86
Xx Karl xX
Rafay

Under scrutiny (1 point)

ABigDeer
Alternate_Tree
Daimos

Most likely to be scum (0 points)

Angel Cruz dela Sant
Cam177
OrangeRush7
Reign of Terror

[KevinH]

Posts in the last 24 hours:
BeeBs: 1
KevinH: 1
Everyone else: 0

[Rafay]

Well I have nothing to say. This is only my 2nd game. I need to think from some experienced player's words. ccbal86????

[ccabal86]

You know, I though this game was already dead, but it appears it's vitals are coming back!

Allrighty, so a certain Dr. Jekyll is dead, who appeared to be SANE. Going off the story of the original, I wonder if this is some sort of changing role...And if yes, what would the Mr. Hide variant be? I'd say definitely NOT sane, and likely violent... Maybe we have our Serial Killer? Some sort of Serial Killer role with a twist?

[BeeBs]

+1 point for being probed again: Electric Mango

Are you jumping to conclusions here? ElectricMango, did I miss a specification about what you detect? Did you find out your were prodded by scum or just prodded? I don't mean to cast any doubt on your character in the game, I'm just wondering exactly what is available from the information you gather at night.

You know, I though this game was already dead, but it appears it's vitals are coming back!

Allrighty, so a certain Dr. Jekyll is dead, who appeared to be SANE. Going off the story of the original, I wonder if this is some sort of changing role...And if yes, what would the Mr. Hide variant be? I'd say definitely NOT sane, and likely violent... Maybe we have our Serial Killer? Some sort of Serial Killer role with a twist?

Jeez, I can't believe this didn't occur to me. Logistically it seems difficult to implement in a mafia game, but that doesn't mean it didn't happen. Sounds like a solid idea based on the flavor of the role, however I doubt that he actually flipped factions. Maybe just able to have a townie faction NK every other night?

[Xx Karl xX]

I was thinking about Eva's role, and do you guys think that maybe Eva had a mr Hyde part to the role that allowed for a night kill at the cost of turning into dr. Jekyll and becoming sane? Maybe that's why we had that extra kill on the first night. Although if that's the case, why would Eva waste it on the first night?

[KevinH]

Dr. Jekyll couldn't control Mr. Hyde.
Maybe he had to make a night kill.

[KevinH]

Vote: OrangeRush7

Until somebody gives me a better suggestion, I might as well vote for the inactive.

[Rafay]

Don't waste your vote he has left CN, Game and IRON.

[Rafay]

But inactives are a good idea.


Vote: ABigDeer

[Rafay]

Dis any1 else notice Eva had no sex description in death profile.

[Electric Mango]

I noticed that there was no gender listed as well but don't know what to think of it. Perhaps only the townies(insane) have gender roles or perhaps only the two townies murdered have that description. They were Bonnie and Clyde and were also both Neighborizers. Also, if there is a Doctor Jekyll, maybe Mr Hyde is still alive and out there somewhere. Doctor Jekyll was also a Vet, that probably means that he could protect one of his scum buddies each night, or at least a one shot night action.

Also just to clarify, I'm Mysophobiac Mandy and I'm a clean freak. Because of my disorder, I can detect if anything in my house is disturbed and thus detect that I was targeted. I don't know who targeted me or for what end. I was targeted twice the first night and once on the second. Being targeted twice the first night means that we have several power roles in play. I was targeted twice, either by cops, doc's or most likely, a combination between the two. Also Night 1 there were two deaths, I'm assuming one scum night kill and one from our own vigilante who guessed incorrectly. Night two, I was only targeted one time and there was only one night kill and we got a scum. Why did a townie not die last night? I'm assuming the doc protected me last night because why would the cop investigate me twice. If that's true then why did the scum not rack up a kill?

Even if OrangeRush7 was the Godfather, wouldn't the mod let someone else send in the nk?


Imran Ehsan [Miss Bonnie], Neighborizer♀, was cured in the head on NIGHT 1
JohnGato [Mister Clyde], Neighborizer♂, was shot in the head on NIGHT 1
Eva999 Nerau [Doctor Jekyll], Night-shift Veterinarian, died of an overdose on NIGHT 2

[ccabal86]

Also, if there is a Doctor Jekyll, maybe Mr Hyde is still alive and out there somewhere. Doctor Jekyll was also a Vet, that probably means that he could protect one of his scum buddies each night, or at least a one shot night action.

Eh, I don't know. I seriously doubt a Jekyll/Hide character would be spit into whole players, as it would defeat the whole Bi-polar person flavor, unlike Bonnie & Clyde it makes no sense if it's one person.

[KevinH]

Nerau was inactive and was later shown to be scum.

I told you so.

[BeeBs]

I'm upset that we are on night three and still focusing on inactivity alone as the basis for our votes. I think we would be much better off using vote counts or how people have interacted. What do you all think?

[KevinH]

I agree but there's not much upon which to go.

Rafay (5): ccabal86, Diamos, Electric Mango, BeeBs, Eva999

How about this? Anybody that voted with Eva999 is suspect.

[ccabal86]

By that logic, and your scum probability list, Daimos would be the best candidate to lynch. That is of course if scum didn't scatter their votes on purpouse.

[cam177]

it seems were jumping around here and for those wantingto vote inactives ill admit it is a thought but if their inactive it is a waste of a lynch best to go for those that are active so we have more info to go on