638 replies to this topic

[Xx Karl xX]

Well, assuming we get alternate tree's info and we believe it, I think we'd have a lot of info to work with already.

Is it a good idea to get alternate tree's info now before he dies and go from that? Even if it just confirms townies?

We can't get Alternate tree's info right now because he said he doesn't know the results of his investigations until after he dies, so the only way to find out what he's found out is to kill him

[Alternate_Tree]

So that's the dilemma, I've investigated 3 people, all of whom are still alive. So is it worth it to lynch me to get info, or to wait and potentially lose more people before getting the info. If I'm going to be killed by a lynching, that uses up a day for lynching, so waiting longer may not be the best plan either.

[Daimos]

So that's the dilemma, I've investigated 3 people, all of whom are still alive. So is it worth it to lynch me to get info, or to wait and potentially lose more people before getting the info. If I'm going to be killed by a lynching, that uses up a day for lynching, so waiting longer may not be the best plan either.

Which 3 people did you investigate?

[Alternate_Tree]

I will not be revealing who I investigated because there are still at least 3 scum, and they benefit the most from seeing who I actually investigated. That information I will hold back as there is no real benefit to knowing 3 names without any information behind it

[Xx Karl xX]

Well, i think that since we have no clue who any of the scum could be, lynching Alternate is the best bet so we will at least get some info as to who to lynch after him. So:

Vote: Alternate_Tree

[Xx Karl xX]

Forgot to bold it

vote: Alternate_Tree

[Kaziocore]

Alternate Tree (3): ccabal86, Rafay, Xx Karl xX
ABigDeer (1): d3mon
Angel Cruz dela Sant (1): KevinH

Not Voting (7): ABigDeer, Alternate_Tree, Angel Cruz dela Sant, BeeBs, cam177, Daimos, Electric Mango

With 12 Alive, 7 is needed to lynch.
4 is needed to lynch on deadline.
Deadline is in 6 days

Both ABigDeer and Angel needs to be replaced

Edited by Kaziocore, 21 July 2012 - 02:06 AM.

[KevinH]

If we lynch the cop, we'll get information about 3 of the 11 remaining players.
We'll know nothing about the other 8 players.

If we don't lynch the cop, we'll get information about 4 players with 10 or 11 players remaining.
Even if random killings occur and take out those he has investigated, he can stay 3 ahead.
When there are only 4 players left, it will be time to lynch the cop.

[Rafay]

If we don't lynch him then the mafia will kill him as he role claimed and again we'll be left with only info for 3 people.

[KevinH]

By lynching the cop:

• Dead townie (cop himself lynched)
• Info on 3 people

Worst case by not lynching the cop:

• Dead townie (cop himself nightkilled)
• Info on 3 people

Best case by not lynching the cop:

• Nobody else dies
• Info on 12 people

The totally best case is too much to hope for but random killings might kill scum and we'll get more info each day the cop lives.

[cam177]

Okay I just got back anyone mind filling me is on what is exactly happening it seems ive missed quite a bit/

[d3mon]

If we don't lynch him then the mafia will kill him as he role claimed and again we'll be left with only info for 3 people.

Doesn't matter cuz we will find the clues. Also, atm it looks like mafia cannot night kill.

Also, I think you shared your type of insanity but I am having trouble finding the post, would you help me out by repeating it.

[Xx Karl xX]

Okay I just got back anyone mind filling me is on what is exactly happening it seems ive missed quite a bit/

We found out that Alternate_Tree is a cop, but can't share his investigations until he dies, and also that apparently the mod chooses random people to go crazy and kill another person. I think that's everything we've learned so far.

[Rafay]

@ d3mon

I have Delirium, means all objects of various shapes and sizes interest me. And if something is displaced I find about it ( that's not a role but the insanity )

[cam177]

We found out that Alternate_Tree is a cop, but can't share his investigations until he dies, and also that apparently the mod chooses random people to go crazy and kill another person. I think that's everything we've learned so far.

Okay that is good news depending on how you look at it

[ccabal86]

MOD: I would like to officially request a replacement, if possible, as I can no longer dedicate enough time.

Sorry guys

[KevinH]

He must be scum!

[Kaziocore]

MOD: I would like to officially request a replacement, if possible, as I can no longer dedicate enough time.

Well that would mean we will need 2 more replacements.
I already found a replacement for Angel

[Kaziocore]

Chaplain of death will immediately replace Angel Cruz dela Sant
Deadline is extended until Friday

[ccabal86]

Alternatively, I can keep playing, but I likely can't follow the discussions very closely or offer much insight