638 replies to this topic

[Chaplain of death]

Problem with that is that they won't target a cop. A scum would target everyone else and get it down to 4 with at least 2 of those 4 being scum. The more you talk about waiting for 4 the more you sound like scum kevin.

[Xx Karl xX]

A strange twist to "follow the cop".
If the night kills are forced kills by random players, why wouldn't we go all the way down to four?
If a scum gets a chance to kill, they will target the cop and we'll start lynching from there.

Im sure there are night kills other than the random ones. Like how imran was cured. so the scum have to have something else, right? if not, that just seems like they would be a little too underpowered.

[KevinH]

If we lynch the cop, we'll get information about 3 of the 11 remaining players.
We'll know nothing about the other 8 players.

If we don't lynch the cop, we'll get information about 4 players with 10 or 11 players remaining.
Even if random killings occur and take out those he has investigated, he can stay 3 ahead.
When there are only 4 players left, it will be time to lynch the cop.

He's now 3 ahead.
If 1 random killing doesn't take out someone he investigated, he'll be 4 ahead and we can lynch him when there are 5 left.
If 2 random killings don't take out someone he investigated, he'll be 5 ahead and we can lynch him when there are 6 left.
If 3 random killings don't take out someone he investigated, he'll be 6 ahead and we can lynch him when there are 7 left.
...

The point is that we should not lynch the cop. If he doesn't die, we have the best chance of winning.

There's a chance that when it gets down to 6, that 3 of the revealed investigations would be scum. But just like any other game, it best to play the odds.

[cam177]

If we lynch the cop, we'll get information about 3 of the 11 remaining players.
We'll know nothing about the other 8 players.

If we don't lynch the cop, we'll get information about 4 players with 10 or 11 players remaining.
Even if random killings occur and take out those he has investigated, he can stay 3 ahead.
When there are only 4 players left, it will be time to lynch the cop.

Just a different perspective on this you can quite easily get tons of info out of those three unless their all insane; but if they are we can go for the ones who quickly defended someone when their about to be lynched if they are sane.

Just a thought

[Chaplain of death]

I'm not saying you should lynch the cop yet. Just saying its interesting how you want to wait till the very end knowing for a fact that you are on the of people he investigated. Wouldn't be hard to role claim one of the 3 times mango got pinged. Obviously thats not conclusive enough to warrent any action at this point, but it definatly got me thinking.

[Kaziocore]

Ivan V (2): d3mon, Rafay
Alternate Tree (1): ccabal86

No-lynch (4): KevinH, Xx Karl xX, Chaplain of death, BeeBs

Not Voting (5): Alternate_Tree, cam177, Daimos, Electric Mango, Ivan V

With 12 Alive, 7 is needed to lynch.
4 is needed to lynch on deadline.
Deadline is in 3 days

Ivan V will immediately replace ABigDeer

Edited by Kaziocore, 24 July 2012 - 08:59 AM.

[Rafay]

In that case I hope Ivan is active and since everybody favours Alternate I'll put my confidence in him too.

Unvote: Ivan V

Vote: No-Lynch

[KevinH]

Welcome Ivan V!

If I was scum, I would want to be revealed so my scum buddies could remain anonymous.
After the cop gets more investigations, nobody will be anonymous and scum will be lynched.

As I think about this, all we really need is a majority to be investigated and then revealed at the cop's death.

If there are no scum revealed, the majority can then pick off the uninvestigated with lynches.
If there are scum revealed, the uninvestigated townies will join the investigated townies and lynch the scum until the investigated townies are in the majority and where they can then proceed to pick off the rest of the uninvestigated.
Town wins.

[Alternate_Tree]

I guess we're going with no lynch again.

Vote: No-lynch

[d3mon]

It seems that we are headed for no-lynch and with Ivan V replacing ABD, I have no reason to vote for him

Unvote

Vote : No Lynch

[Electric Mango]

Vote: No Lynch

Let us see what happens next

[BeeBs]

Supposedly Alternate has no idea the outcome of his investigations either. so far as I could tell from his roleclaim. So his voting will have no real insight more then any of the rest of us.

Except that he is our only "confirmed" townie, or at least the closest we have. I'd be more keen to follow someone in his position whether he knows what he is doing or not.

[Kaziocore]

Alternate_Tree (1): ccabal86

No Lynch (8): KevinH, Xx Karl xX, Chaplain of death, BeeBs, Rafay, Alternate_Tree, d3mon, Electric Mango

Not Voting (3): cam177, Daimos, Ivan V

With 12 Alive, 7 is needed to lynch.
4 is needed to lynch on deadline.
Deadline is in 3 days

IT IS NOW NIGHT FOUR.
NIGHT ACTIONS TO ME BY SATURDAY.

Edited by Kaziocore, 25 July 2012 - 02:02 PM.

[Kaziocore]

I'm too lazy to post a scene so here's the picture of Pica Pete before he was cured.



 
KevinH [Pica Pete], Jack-of-all-trades, was cured in the head

It is now DAY 5
Deadline: Friday, 10th of August

With 11 Alive, 6 is needed to lynch.
3 is needed to lynch on deadline

[KevinH]

If you are killed (either via lynch or night kill) you may no longer post except for a brief “Bah!”-type post that contains NO game related information.

Bah!

[Rafay]

Damn KevinH our deducer and researcher is also dead. Who will provide valuable insight and veteran experience to us now. This day we must lynch somebody.

[Daimos]

Damn we lost our most active player. Now what?

[Xx Karl xX]

Damn we lost our most active player. Now what?

well...i think we have a few things we could do:

1. follow Alternate_Tree since he is pretty much the only confirmed townie that's alive

2. we could follow Kevin's list of scum since we know he's a townie

3. lynch inactives? i dunno how useful this would be, but we could still do it haha

[ccabal86]

Gah, I come back and this happens >_>

What could Jack-of all-trades be? Maybe KevinH had all sorts of powers? Anyway, keeping his list in mind would not be a bad idea. We need to lynch today, that's for sure.

[Chaplain of death]

Inactives wouldn't be a bad place to start.