241 replies to this topic

[Commander Shepard]

Vote: Imran Ehsan

 

Screw it, if you're a townie you really didn't help yourself at all.

Lyner get back to voting Imran Ehsan, a no-lynch isn't the end of the world but Imran isn't helpful is trying to do the best for the town. 

Everyone vote to lynch Imran. 

[Imran Ehsan]

on the contrary if you are really the cop your terrible play lost the game for the townies. hopefully you will never get such a power role in any future games.

[Commander Shepard]

Two mistakes occurred, only 1 was my fault:

I assumed the cop killed people because that is what cops do, they don't investigate. I'm not a mafia veteran so my viewpoint was more logical and I only skimmed over description.

I don't think the second thing was my mistake, I'm not a mafia veteran and the right information wasn't given to me about what my results meant in a situation where a player is jailed. 

 

Looking at this from an actual logically point of view the only person fucked up by my gameplay was me.

EM locked me by up twice in a row, first time I couldn't help it but second time I was partly responsible as I was hoping just that the scum would target someone else which they did. They killed EM, I tried to play it smart so I could investigate without getting killed and assumed EM would have figured the scum wouldn't try to kill me if they knew there was a high chance the jailer was going to protect me in their minds.

Up until now, there was only 1 situation where I had a chance to make a difference and that was night 1 with me not visiting anyone but even then there is was only a small chance of me finding scum.

So ultimately even if I didn't roleclaim then this game would probably still suck for the town unless I found scum on Night 1 which would have being unlikely.

 

At this point you deserve to get lynched for everything you tried to pull. 

[Robert2424]

I can't find a reason to doubt CS as the cop. Imran posts continue to add confusion and get us no closer to finding scum. As imran is my top suspect I can believe probably kaz is his partner. You don't try to lynch the cop of all people. Unless you think we are dumb.

Therefore I must make a stand.

VOTEVOTE: IRMAN ESAN

Isoc I don't have very much notes on. But he dose at this time seem to be trying to find scum.

[KevinH]

Vote Count:

• Imran Ehsan (3): Lyner, Commander Shepard, Robert2424
• Kaziocore (1): iSocialism
• Lyner (1):Imran Ehsan
• Commander Shepard (0):
• Robert2424 (0):
• iSocialism (0):
• No-lynch (0):
• ​Not voting: Kaziocore

Imran Ehsan, Compulsive Visitor, has been lynched.

It is now Night 4.

Please send actions by 12:00 EDT on Monday, August 31.

[KevinH]

Day 5 dawns
 
Commander Shepard, Cop, has been night-killed.
iSocialism, Compulsive Visitor, has been shot by a Paranoid Gun Owner.
Kaziocore, Compulsive Visitor, has been shot by a Paranoid Gun Owner.
 
 
Who's left?
 
Lyner, Mafia One-Shot PGO
Robert2424, Mafia One-Shot PGO
 
 
The Scum win!
 
 
Who was who?
 
Killgor: Compulsive Visitor
Rafay: Compulsive Visitor
Montosh: Compulsive Visitor
Electric Mango: Jailkeeper
Imran Ehsan: Compulsive Visitor
Commander Shepard: Cop
iSocialism: Compulsive Visitor
Kaziocore: Compulsive Visitor
Lyner: Mafia One Shot PGO
Robert2424: Mafia One Shot PGO
 
 
What happened?
 
(Uneventful visits are omitted)
 
Day 1
 
No lynch
 
Night 1
 
Lyner night-killed Killgor
Commander Shepard took no action
Electric Mango jailed Imran Ehsan
 
Day 2
 
Rafay was lynched
 
Night 2
 
Electric Mango jailed Commander Shepard
Commander Shepard tried to investigate Montosh but was blocked by being jailed
Robert2424 tried to night-kill Commander Shepard but that failed by jail protection
 
Day 3
 
Montosh was lynched
 
Night 3
 
Electric Mango jailed Commander Shepard
Commander Shepard tried to investigate Imran Ehsan but was blocked by being jailed
Lyner night-killed Electric Mango
 
Day 4
 
Imran Ehsan was lynched
 
Night 4
 
Lyner and Robert2424 armed themselves
Robert2424 night-killed Commander Shepard
iSocialism and Kaziocore were killed by visiting the armed PGOs

Law, Order, and Shallow Relationships have been maintained!

 

Congratulations to Lyner and Robert2424 for the win.

[Robert2424]

GG guys. First game anywhere else I survived and won as mafia.

[Rafay]

Well the town would've won had it not been filled w/ racist losers!!!

[Robert2424]

I do have to say the imran and CS fight was priceless.

[Imran Ehsan]

VOTEVOTE: IRMAN ESAN

 

i should not have been lynched. i dont know who that was being voted for,

 

anyway i was right that lyner was scum..it didnt help that kaz went inactive who probably would have supported me. when the cop jumps to lynch a townie with 2 scums left, game is over anyway.

[Lyner]

Eh the town was too inactive to do anything

 

 

GG

[Robert2424]

Lol. Trying to post from my phone is a pain.

[Commander Shepard]

This game ended days ago but yeah the scum didn't do anything special.

Doesn't matter about Kaz, it's an opinion who is scummy when they don't add much to the game, ultimately the role of Lyner and robert in winning the game was so minimal because of all the errors that they could have done nothing and still win.

 

Lynching Imran wasn't an error, he deserved to be lynched. 

[Lyner]

Blame time?   

[Commander Shepard]

The game was pretty horrendous, calling it a good game with such inactivity is an insult to good games. 

[Imran Ehsan]

Well I agree it was a horrendous game. Not only was it CS making terrible calls, other veteran townie players also played bad or went inactive (kaz).

 

CS Horrendous Play list

 

1. Reads role that say COP. Thinks cops are ones who kill innocent people instead of the universal definition of cops arraest criminals. Takes no action.

2. Belatedly (and unfortunately for the town), realizes the true nature of a cop. calls for the lynch of townie Montosh and affects his lynch even knowing there is 33% chance Montosh is scum (he could have himself been RBed, JK could  have RBed town Montosh or JK could have RBed scum Montosh). 

3. Asks for the JK to protect him at night (unfortunately for the town). This not only stopped him from being killed which would have actually helped the town but also was a completely horrendous request considering he would have known the JK would have blocked him from doing any night action.

4. Goes ballistic and OMGUS votes for me, even knowing if I am not scum there are 2 scum left and game will be over.

5. Unvotes and goes ballistic again voting for me when I pointed out No lynching helps town in no way and I actually put my vote on the real scum.

[Commander Shepard]

I made clear 2) wasn't my fault while the game was still running. I made clear 3) as well, I was counting on EM to know better than to target me. 

My post was more to let the scum know than to let EM know. 

 

4) You went mental for no reason at me. Yeah I didn't care if you were scum, you played better as scum than the scum anyway so congrats. 

5) No lynching could have helped, I probably die and you guys could continue on.

 

The scum could have being Kaz for all you knew, your hunch was worthless at the time because it was based on little to nothing that other players probably were also guilty of. 

But yeah you should have said "Lyner is always scum", I might have thought better of you then. 

[Kaziocore]

Yeah sorry about this one. I ruined the game for everyone for not staying active.

[Imran Ehsan]

The scum could have being Kaz for all you knew, your hunch was worthless at the time because it was based on little to nothing that other players probably were also guilty of. But yeah you should have said "Lyner is always scum", I might have thought better of you then.

 

It wasnt a hunch. If you were not scum and I knew I a not scum, that means 2 of kaz, isoc, robert and lyner were scum. You unvoted me which gave you townie points and iSoc didnt vote for either you or me (scum will be looking for a lynch) so it left 2 of lyner, robert or kaz. since kaz was inactive we had no read of him but of the remaining two lyner was the most scummy considering he jumped on the easy bandwagon early looking for a lynch.

 

its not that hard to reason through it..instead of seeing red everytime someone votes for you or questions your motives.

You went mental for no reason at me. Yeah I didn't care if you were scum, you played better as scum than the scum anyway so congrats.

 

lol...only the scum supported you when you went for my lynch. so it was only you who went ballistic.

[Commander Shepard]

It was only 50% townie active at that point, so the only way for a non scum member to get lynched was to have scum support.