1277 replies to this topic

[Robert2424]

Well. Process of elimination. We have an even voyoger. Though shouldn't claim. Though tw not performing an action perplexes me as much as yehom.

[Road2Victory]

Could TW and yehom be on the same team, along with Perez?

[Robert2424]

Could TW and yehom be on the same team, along with Perez?

Anything is possible, and roles are selected at random. Scum team could consist of anybody. 

[Shahenshah]

Well. Process of elimination. We have an even voyoger. Though shouldn't claim. Though tw not performing an action perplexes me as much as yehom.

You must mean voyeur because I spent last 10 mins googling what voyoger dies. -.-

Could TW and yehom be on the same team, along with Perez?

Anything is possible, and roles are selected at random. Scum team could consist of anybody. 

And Rafey.

[Robert2424]

Spelling in a hurry on my phone is not my forte. I should of left a note that I knew it was spelled wrong, but Work was busy. 

[iSocialism]

As always, with the claim FB please state your character name.

So is there such a thing as a even/odd mafia team?

[Lyner]

 

Crap, I missed it.

 

I hope R2V didn't watch Samus last night

@Lyner - I'm confused about this. Aren't we hoping that R2V can provide us with the list of people that targeted Samus? At least then we are guaranteed to at least have one name in front of us (even if we have to sort that person out of the list of people that targeted Samus).

 

 

Samus is Ascetic so any actions targeting him (except "kills") would be blocked, watching him would result on nothing

 

 

 

 

 

 

Samus, you fool!!!

 

For example, an Ascetic Cop cannot be Roleblocked, but also cannot be protected by a Doctor.

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Ascetic

So basically if he was slotted for night kill there was no way to stop that?

 

The way I understand it: yes. And the Mafia knew this apparantly and most townies didn't.

 

So Lyner spotted this after the fact   (he's town) and I suppose an experienced player like EM would've spotted this as well. (or another experienced player) TW knew it seems, so maybe he spotted it and told the rest of his scum friends, but I doubt it as it's his 1st game, but who knows, he's smart.

 

 

Yes I missed it, my bad

 

Also where do you get this information: "Many players went to the first player to place his vote. Unfortunately (for the town), one of those players made a kill." ?

                   

[Robert2424]

Yeah. I'm unclear how we know several people visited him?

[Road2Victory]

Yeah. I'm unclear how we know several people visited him?

Same here

[Mandarijn]

It's just in Kevin's post:

Leia Organa the townie Motion Detector had been lynched.

Many players went to the first player to place his vote. Unfortunately (for the town), one of those players made a kill.

Samus, Vanilla Townie Universal Backup who became Ascetic Sane Cop, has been killed in the night.

It is now Day 3. With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch or 4 at deadline.
Deadline is Tuesday, February 23, at noon EST.

 

 

It seems everyone (of town at least) has a role, so this:

 

I'll claim even follower. I followed TW. He performed no actions last night.

 

confirms my suspicion of TW even more as we already have 2 odd roles in town, so if he was town he would have a role (even or normal) and would have indeed performed an action... Only 1 member of the Mafia will perform the kill, so the others would be sitting doing nothing.

 

So I'm just going to go for it:

Vote TW

 

 

Besides that I think our 2 lurkers: Rafay and Perez are good candidates of being scum, together with Yehom and EM (and who knows Imran, but I still believe he's pro-town, otherwise he's just playing it very well. )

[Rafay]

And Rafey.

 

 

Why me?

 

And also why aren't we asking the ppl for explanations on their stupid vote on Rusken yesterday....

[Mandarijn]

 

And Rafey.

 

 

Why me?

 

And also why aren't we asking the ppl for explanations on their stupid vote on Rusken yesterday....

 

Because you don't say much, but still are active... + You didn't vote for anyone the previous day.

 

Stupid vote? This also tells me you haven't really been reading what's going on... You just rose another spot on my Mafia list.

Everyone who didn't vote for Rusken is actually more suspicious in my eyes as either they haven't been following what's going on OR they knew more than us...

[Shahenshah]

 

And Rafey.

 

 

Why me?

 

And also why aren't we asking the ppl for explanations on their stupid vote on Rusken yesterday....

 

1. Because you've not contributed at all in putting the pieces together or give input.

2. Because you've been lurking. 

3. The above two actions are not pro-town. Staying silent only and only helps mafia, that is what you have done for majority of the game so far.  

 

I havent played in a while with all those roles and stuff, but I did play basic long back on RnR forums and lurking is considered to be the worst thing you can do as a townie, so. 

[Mandarijn]

Post count (+ my 'certain' townies list):

Robert2424 101 (town)

Samus 74

Road2Victory 73 (town)

Rusken 72

KevinH 65

iSocialism 53

Mandarijn 49 (town)

Imran Ehsan 41

Finster Baby 39 (town)

The Warrior 29 (SCUM)

Yehom 27

Electric Mango 25

Shahenshah 24  (town)

Perez 21

Rafay 17

Lyner 13  (town)

Kaziocore 8

Fox Fire 1

Commander Shepard 1

 

[Shahenshah]

 

Post count (+ my 'certain' townies list):

Robert2424 101 (town)

Samus 74

Road2Victory 73 (town)

Rusken 72

KevinH 65

iSocialism 53

Mandarijn 49 (town)

Imran Ehsan 41

Finster Baby 39 (town)

The Warrior 29 (SCUM)

Yehom 27

Electric Mango 25

Shahenshah 24  (town)

Perez 21

Rafay 17

Lyner 13  (town)

Kaziocore 8

Fox Fire 1

Commander Shepard 1

 

 

Imagine if you had forgotten to put (town) ahead of your name, lol. 

 

Good post and puts some things in perspectives, In office, I'll make detailed reply later in the day. 

 

We still have time so I'd not want to rush on any wagon at this stage, given how things turned out with Rusken. We simply cannot afford another similar scenario. I'm still bit lost with some mechanics, so I'll need to recollect and organised thoughts in my head. My tinfoil radar is on over-drive

[KevinH]

Q: What side of an Ewok has the most hair?
A: The outside.




Vote Count

Yehom (1): Robert2424,
The Warrior (1): Mandarijn,
Robert2424 (0):
Imran Ehsan (0):
Road2Victory (0):
Electric Mango (0):
Shahenshah (0): 
Perez (0):
Lyner (0):
Rafay (0):
iSocialism (0):
Mandarijn (0):
Finster Baby (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: The Warrior, Lyner, Rafay, Road2Victory, Imran Ehsan, Shahenshah, Electric Mango, Finster Baby, Perez, Yehom, iSocialism,

 
With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch or 4 at deadline.
Deadline is Tuesday, February 23, at noon EST.
 

[Lyner]

It's just in Kevin's post:

Leia Organa the townie Motion Detector had been lynched.

Many players went to the first player to place his vote. Unfortunately (for the town), one of those players made a kill.

Samus, Vanilla Townie Universal Backup who became Ascetic Sane Cop, has been killed in the night.

 

 

Well now after knowing the context it is getting more curious. Correct me if I'm wrong but those sentences could imply that "the one who made a kill" is among the people who voted to lynch Leia   

[Shahenshah]

It's just in Kevin's post:

Leia Organa the townie Motion Detector had been lynched.

Many players went to the first player to place his vote. Unfortunately (for the town), one of those players made a kill.

Samus, Vanilla Townie Universal Backup who became Ascetic Sane Cop, has been killed in the night.

Well now after knowing the context it is getting more curious. Correct me if I'm wrong but those sentences could imply that "the one who made a kill" is among the people who voted to lynch Leia

Good observation Sir.

[Imran Ehsan]

 

 

Samus, you fool!!!

 

For example, an Ascetic Cop cannot be Roleblocked, but also cannot be protected by a Doctor.

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Ascetic

So basically if he was slotted for night kill there was no way to stop that?

 

R2V, is most likely what he says he is. We just need him to come forward. Anyone that had been trying to discredit should be on everyone watch list. Also Imran I'm pretty sure after being on two lynch wagons, you might know exactly what's going on.

Considering a townie rallied the lynch wagon, that's a bad argument. 

 

Imran has given very little input on who he think scum is, like a long list. He more rides the wave of everyone else.

 

 

False. I have posted who I think scum and townie are a lot more than most of the players in this game has: http://ironcentral.org/community/topic/55574-kh-11-the-force-awakens-mafia-day-3/?p=826076

 

Note that I had pegged Rusken to be town at that point. But he really acted scummily after that which made not only me but the majority of the players suspect him as scum.

 

And your other point holds no water. If I was bndwagoning I would have been in the middle or towards the end of the wagons not in the beginning. FF, I was first to vote for. Rusken I was second. Scum would ride on the wagons created by others not be on the forefront. Other ppl wagoned on who I was voting for on that day not the other way around.

 

Anyway, I am more suspicious of those who were not on the Rusken wagon. Rusken was acting extremely scummily and it seems only the scum knew for sure he was townie and held off on jumping on that wagon knowing very well he will get lynched whether they voted for him or not.

[Robert2424]

Though tw has perplexes me. He hasn't had the same opportunity as yehom to defend himself. Though I don't think yehom has done a very good job in his own defense. Should be interesting what tw has to say after being followed last night or he calls fin a liar.