1277 replies to this topic

[Road2Victory]

Hmmm that raises suspicions of him even more, he did say in the past he also wanted me to be lynched but Rusken beat me over it. 

[Yehom]

with the assumption that everyone has a role, I think no-lynch might be an option.

I actually like this a lot. We have too little information to work with at this moment. The chances are that we are going to lynch a townie versus lynching someone that's mafia are higher as well. Another night means more information, which means we can make a more educated decision. 

[Shahenshah]

I do this every time I read Rusken --> 

 

A general query, what's this tangent about everyone having abilities? What's the context to this? Sorry I havent played a game with so many roles and this size. I generally played the vanilla version on RnR forums. What does this mean and signify?

[Mandarijn]

We've had 2 nights already and have like zero info, why do you all think we'll have more info in the next night? We'll just be in the same situation again...

 

Because only 1 of the 4/5 Mafia guys will do the kill (and maybe 1 more has an ability), so the chances aren't very high that we will effectively kill someone.

 

We will be better of lynching TW, Rafay (he clearly still doesn't know what he's talking about, plus he's also not sharing any of his thoughts, just like Yehom) or Yehom in my eyes. Perez and EM are a good bet as well, but they seem more inactive than lurking.

[Yehom]

Haven't seen Rafay post now you mention it. When was his last post?

[Finster Baby]

Well look what I found. Finster Baby voted to lynch both Fox and Rusken!!
 
Mistake or carefully calculated removal.

1. FF was inactive, this is why I voted for her.
2. I jumped on the Rusken bandwagon with everyone else. I was fairly certain he was scum. I was wrong.

I've also announced a role, so there's that.

While I believe that voting allows more trends to come out and let us find out with some certainty who is scum and who isn't, also considering that we have a lot of night roles identified here, I believe a No Lynch here is in order. I'd rather give us one more day to figure out who's who in the zoo than potentially lynch another ally to keep us alive.

VOTE: NO LYNCH

[Mandarijn]

Haven't seen Rafay post now you mention it. When was his last post?

C'mon, just tell us what you think...

[Yehom]

I think that at this moment in time no lynching is better than trying to guess who is mafia. There is almost no information on the table what so ever to work with. Nobody is particularly suspicious in my eyes, maybe those who are a little bit inactive, but nobody is really standing out. Give the town another night, another round to get some information and we can make a better decision. 

 

Vote No Lynch

[Shahenshah]

Haven't seen Rafay post now you mention it. When was his last post?

He posted like 2 hrs before you bro.

 

[Robert2424]

I don't think Yehom is caring about anybody posts who might be against him at this point. 

 

Course, I asked TW a q and he still hasn't answered me. 

 

No lynch would of been better on day 1. The info that we have and info thats swirling around dosn't help with a no lynch now. We suspect scum has a Role Blocker. This role blocker will target one of the odd people, while the maifa would attempt to kill anouther, then switch to the evens the next. 

 

At the same time we don't know if there is one big scum team or they've been devided into two. (An Even, and an Odd mafia). A no lynch at this point in the game isn't ideal. I'll at least stand against it. They mafia has proven thus far they aren't new to the game and have an experenced player within there ranks going after Samus and knowing there kill would go through while most of us didn't even pick up on it. I see the Risks out weighs the rewards, its not like everyone can use a night action. There are odds and even. 

[KevinH]

Q: What do Star Destroyers wear to parties?
A: A bow TIE.




Vote Count

Yehom (1): Robert2424,
The Warrior (1): Mandarijn,
Perez (1): iSocialism,
Robert2424 (0):
Imran Ehsan (0):
Road2Victory (0):
Electric Mango (0):
Shahenshah (0): 
Lyner (0):
Rafay (0):
iSocialism (0):
Mandarijn (0):
Finster Baby (0):

No Lynch (2): Finster Baby, Yehom,

Not voting: The Warrior, Lyner, Rafay, Road2Victory, Imran Ehsan, Shahenshah, Electric Mango, Perez,

 
With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch or 4 at deadline.
Deadline is Tuesday, February 23, at noon EST.
 

[Finster Baby]

I should qualify my vote to state that I can be convinced that a different action is the better action, of course.

[Rafay]

We've had 2 nights already and have like zero info, why do you all think we'll have more info in the next night? We'll just be in the same situation again...  

 

That's what I said but then I was labelled mafia scum? We have now a better chance of playing if we don't lynch.

 

Vote: No-Lynch 

 

2. I jumped on the Rusken bandwagon with everyone else. I was fairly certain he was scum. I was wrong.

 

Well your excitement didn't help.....

 

VOTE: NO LYNCH

 

Good call or pressure much? 

[Finster Baby]

We've had 2 nights already and have like zero info, why do you all think we'll have more info in the next night? We'll just be in the same situation again...

 
That's what I said but then I was labelled mafia scum? We have now a better chance of playing if we don't lynch.
 
Vote: No-Lynch 
 
 
 

2. I jumped on the Rusken bandwagon with everyone else. I was fairly certain he was scum. I was wrong.

 
Well your excitement didn't help.....
 
 
 

VOTE: NO LYNCH

 
Good call or pressure much?

I'm looking out for the town's interest...we certainly can't take another loss through an incorrect lynch. Unless we're 95% certain who we're lynching is actually scum, I'm not sure we can take a chance.

[Mandarijn]

I agree we should lynch someone, we already lost our cop, so I suppose we will never have 100% evidence. Unless someone follows/watches the specific mafia guy that makes the kill, but that's just a slim chance... So I'm not convinced that we'll have any more info tomorrow if we don't lynch now.

 

I would ut my money on TW. If not him, Rafay or Yehom could do as well. But I'm not as sure about them as I'm with TW.

I know him, if he wasn't scum he would be way more involved, which he really isn't... Think about this: If TW wasn't scum, there would be at least 1, maybe 2 scums that would jump on my wagon to try and lynch him. No one is backing me, I understand the townies as the evidence isn't 100%, but this gives me sufficient info that he is indeed scum. I still have to hear a better theory than mine to lynch someone else. Same could be said for Yehom and Perez actually, although the evidence isn't as good. Although chances are pretty high Yehom is scum as well, as he refuses to tell us what he thinks.

[Rafay]

I'm looking out for the town's interest...

 

I certainly hope you are bro......

[Mandarijn]

Mafia will of course be jumping on the no lynch wagon as well, as this is beneficial for them. Except if they can lynch a townie, but it seems we're going in the right direction now and they can't jump on a wagon...

[Finster Baby]

I agree we should lynch someone, we already lost our cop, so I suppose we will never have 100% evidence. Unless someone follows/watches the specific mafia guy that makes the kill, but that's just a slim chance... So I'm not convinced that we'll have any more info tomorrow if we don't lynch now.
 
I would ut my money on TW. If not him, Rafay or Yehom could do as well. But I'm not as sure about them as I'm with TW.
I know him, if he wasn't scum he would be way more involved, which he really isn't... Think about this: If TW wasn't scum, there would be at least 1, maybe 2 scums that would jump on my wagon to try and lynch him. No one is backing me, I understand the townies as the evidence isn't 100%, but this gives me sufficient info that he is indeed scum. I still have to hear a better theory than mine to lynch someone else. Same could be said for Yehom and Perez actually, although the evidence isn't as good. Although chances are pretty high Yehom is scum as well, as he refuses to tell us what he thinks.

TW had my interest last round, but after his no action over night, I'm slightly less suspicious. That said, yeah, scum don't necessarily have to take an action over night. He very well may be scummy.

Just hard to tell right now, and the more experienced hands haven't weighed in yet.

[Mandarijn]

It seems everyone (of town at least) has a role, so this:

 

 

 

I'll claim even follower. I followed TW. He performed no actions last night.

confirms my suspicion of TW even more as we already have 2 odd roles in town, so if he was town he would have a role (even or normal) and would have indeed performed an action... Only 1 member of the Mafia will perform the kill, so the others would be sitting doing nothing.

 

Finster, to me that just confirms he's scum.

All townies have a role, but we already have 2 odd roles (who couldn't use their action in N2), so I really don't see any other reason why he didn't use his action if he was town... It's very unlikely we have 3 odd roles. He said there are plenty of reasons why someone wouldn't use his night action, but it seems he doesn't know any as he didn't give me any reason. (He had a lot of time to find a good reason in the wiki now or ask a good explanation to his buddies)

 

So everyone who doesn't use a night action is suspicious to me (except the ones that claimed odd and even roles). So Robert, you tracked Yehom on the 1st night and he also didn't perform a night action, right? He also didn't know what you meant with odd / even, so he doesn't have an odd/even role. So he's probably scum as well, unless he can give a good explanation why he didn't use his action.

 

 

Do we already know who the 2nd even role is? (You don't have to specify anything else if you don't want to)

[iSocialism]

Maddies is right, the whole no action used is suspicious. The only thing a can think of is a one shot. However, now that roles have been claimed and we're expecting a experienced/knowledgeable scum leader. We can assume that they would go after TW if they knew he wasn't scum. Knowing that he might have a one shot kill. They would also have a person commit the action that is already on our scum list, or a player who is playing a great game and is consider town amongst the players. Hopefully, they're not all inexperienced, got lucky on the samus target, and I just told them what to do.  

 

Yehom, I Don't buy it. you have to know something, or at least have opinions about someone.

 

Vote Yehom