1277 replies to this topic

[KevinH]

Sometime the Resistance survives.

Nobody died in the night.

It is now Day 5.
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.
Deadline is Thursday, March 17 at 17:00 EDT.

[Yehom]

Guys what have you all seen this night?

[The Warrior]

I guess our protective roles chose correctly! Nice job folks! Now we have work to do.

@Finster - What did you see?

Does anyone else have any information from their actions?

[Perez]

You...guys...

....

....

...suck

 

*DEAD* 

[Finster Baby]

I followed EM.

Electric Mango did not go anywhere.

[Imran Ehsan]

Interesting. Seems like someone got protected at night.

protected successfully I mean

[iSocialism]

Is there a chance that there is an even night SK?

[Imran Ehsan]

Is there a chance that there is an even night SK?

 

we got the extra kill on the odd night. So if there is a SK it is likely it is odd-night aligned not even.

[Lyner]

Well where is Shah and why did he disappear yesterday

[Shahenshah]

    FFS, can we get one lynch right? Can  we be more cautious please?

 

I'll be posting over the weekend and go over the stuff I've missed. I'm having a bit of sporadic activity due to work so I'm not really engaging anywhere where it requires me to use brain cells . (I posted in other thread I was stuck in RL) I wasn't 100% convinced about Perez and was very cautious because we always mislynch and therefore I chose not to vote (and no I'm not saying this  after-the-fact, I've said this before that I thought Perez was suspicious, but was due to noob errors). 

 

Anyway, Lyner, I'll share the details. I'm glad about the protections working out fine, I'm also confident about the protections for next night. Now had you guys forced me to blurt everything out, we'd have had a huge increased chance of night kill. First they just had to keep you and Yehom in the arithmatic, now there's another unknown variable. 

 

Since I'm being v. cautious, I was somewhat convinced about EM being smelly, but iSoc, since Samus could be D1 vanilla, perhaps that was the initial hint from EM. Also, I dont like your ruse at all. I'd rather have mafia lynch a vanilla townie than someone more important and that was also part of my dispute with Yehom (unearthing everything out for Mafia) but we figured that out. I'm suspecting you now more because you self-admittedly lied, and we have nothing useful to show for that manouvre and then you bandwagoned on Perez at the last moment. I think you and EM are on the same team and that your dispute with EM was a ruse too. You yourself switched votes after saying Samus could be also vanilla. 

 

Sometimes, I feel some of our actions are counter-productive. 

 

My suspect list:

iSoc - all the flip flops last day, and probably in team with EM.

Finster - You dont show up much, but when you do, you dont really see much... 

Ccabal ~~~ because he's been afk for quite sometime now. 

~EM ~~~ he's like semi-afk/semi-lurk/semi-inactive, probably in team with iSoc

 

 

Lyner, my weekend is Fri-Sat, so allow me the time to share enough information that it's sufficient enough and doesn't affect the future. I just wish I had some smoking-gun to sell you, I have the gun's cover, the gun I gotta keep for later use, if you know what I mean. 

[Imran Ehsan]

Vote Count
Perez (5): Imran Ehsan, Lyner, Yehom, Finster Baby, iSocialism,

OK. My preliminary thoughts:

- I would say there is at least 2 scum in the above list.

 

- Also there probably isn't 4 scum but 3. We did not see a rush of votes to end the lynch day. So the scum were careful which indicates they knew they will have to go through another day to win.

 

- With the extra kill on N3, I am now thinking there are 3 scum + 1 SK with the SK having X-shot or odd night ability.

 

- I am interested to hear if TW commuted last night. I realize this may leave him open for a night kill but its pretty much a do or die scenario today. If he did not commute our protective roles saved a townie tonight.

 

- I had a successful use of my action last night as well. But I want to hear from iSocialism (his response to Shah), ccabal and EM first before i reveal the result.

[Finster Baby]

My suspect list:

Finster - You dont show up much, but when you do, you dont really see much...

You know, scum, I'm sick and tired of being accused by you of being scum, when it's clear I've been acting in the town's best interests.

Therefore:

VOTE: Shahenshah

You have much to prove to me before I'll even consider removing my vote. Your continued sniping of me and my novice play (and that's the way it should be characterized, as this is my first game in YEARS) has grown weary.

You can lynch me. You'll find out just like we did with Perez that you're mistaken.

[Shahenshah]

 

My suspect list:

Finster - You dont show up much, but when you do, you dont really see much...

You know, scum, I'm sick and tired of being accused by you of being scum, when it's clear I've been acting in the town's best interests.

Therefore:

VOTE: Shahenshah

You have much to prove to me before I'll even consider removing my vote. Your continued sniping of me and my novice play (and that's the way it should be characterized, as this is my first game in YEARS) has grown weary.

You can lynch me. You'll find out just like we did with Perez that you're mistaken.

 

That is your prerogative Finster, do note, I havent actually lynch-voted for you, which is quite different from suspicion and I'm not going to do that currently either. I'd rather abstain after all the wrong lynches. If we had seriously considered the no-vote option that I had brought up last night, on which I got grilled, even tho admittedly, I was tilting more towards voting, but just bringing that up got me the flak, if we had instead considered it more thoughtfully, we'd have Perez alive today.  

 

If you do want to vote for me because 'OMG im tired of your finger-pointing', pls do go ahead. If you really do have townies best interest in mind, you'd put your vote in on a much more solid reasoning. Think about it. I pointed finger at you, please feel free to do the same, I didnt actually vote for you, but you're offcourse free to vote for me and then I'll just highlight that the reasoning you've provided is really flimsy and it just raises the suspicion. Sure, I do carry the suspicion until I deliver what I have promised but just you're just being so reckless with your vote despite us getting ALL the lynches wrong, I think that's a red flag and it's having exactly the opposite effect than what you intend.  We're ONE wrong vote away from defeat and you're voting because 'OMG'. 

[KevinH]

www.jokes4us.com/celebrityjokes/starwarsjokes.html

 

(you didn't think I made them up myself, did you?)

Vote Count

Shahenshah (1): Finster Baby,
The Warrior (0): 
Electric Mango (0): 
Yehom (0):
iSocialism (0):
Imran Ehsan (0):
ccabal86 (0):
Lyner (0):
Finster Baby (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Electric Mango, The Warrior, ccabal86, Shahenshah, Imran Ehsan, Lyner, Yehom,  iSocialism,

 
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.
Deadline is Thursday, March 17 at 17:00 EDT.

[The Warrior]

 

Is there a chance that there is an even night SK?

 

we got the extra kill on the odd night. So if there is a SK it is likely it is odd-night aligned not even.

 

Is it more likely that we have an "Odd-Night" or "X-Shot" Serial Killer or Vigilante? 

 

There was a second kill on night 3. So one of the following has to be true:

1) If we have an "Odd-Night" SK or Vigilante, he would have likely tried to kill on night 1 as well. This means that his target would have had to be protected since there was no night 1 kill.

2) If we have an "X-Shot" SK or Vigilante, it could be possible that they have used multiple shots already, one being successful on night 3 and the others being blocked.

3) If we have an "X-Shot" SK or Vigilante, it could be possible that they only had a 1-shot ability and have used it up.

4) We have a SK or Vig with terrible luck that keeps trying to kill people who are protected and has only managed to get one kill through.

5) There is a second scum faction and both factions have terrible luck in targeting. (This is the least likely option in my opinion.)

 

If we do have a SK or Vig, I think that it's pretty clear that the person has some sort of modifier. Either that or they have extremely terrible luck and keep targeting people that we protect.

 

What else did anyone find out last night? Who did our protective roles choose to protect? We might be able to figure out who could have been targeted.

[iSocialism]

Well, I believe TW, Yehom, and Lyner roles. With that, and counting myself out. That leaves 5 which could be 4 scums and one sk. it's going to be fast and little explanation, but the opposite has gotten many town lynched.

 

Vote Shah

[The Warrior]

We have to do something today because the chances of surviving another night are not great, but I think that we need to hear more of what happened last night before doing anything. If we incorrectly lynch today, the game is over before we even get a chance to survive the night. We have eight days to figure things out. 

[Shahenshah]

Well, I believe TW, Yehom, and Lyner roles. With that, and counting myself out. That leaves 5 which could be 4 scums and one sk. it's going to be fast and little explanation, but the opposite has gotten many town lynched.

 

Vote Shah

Like your last minute Perez vote

 

Apparently, sharing suspect lists now get you revenge lynch votes. Looks like an attempt to stifle any discussion and create a wagon real quick. A mind wanders. 

[Imran Ehsan]

Interesting turn of events. I would rather hear from everyone first before lynching someone. Todays lynch is crucial. So we need to be absolutely sure.

 

IS EM inactive? Mod, can we get a ping on him?

[iSocialism]

 

Well, I believe TW, Yehom, and Lyner roles. With that, and counting myself out. That leaves 5 which could be 4 scums and one sk. it's going to be fast and little explanation, but the opposite has gotten many town lynched.

 

Vote Shah

Like your last minute Perez vote

 

Apparently, sharing suspect lists now get you revenge lynch votes. Looks like an attempt to stifle any discussion and create a wagon real quick. A mind wanders. 

 

yeah, if I wouldn't have voted he would have survived.

 

TW is a commuter, Ccabal is most likely luke skywalker and I believe to be town. Yehom I believe as the bodyguard, and lyner as another town player. Leaving me with Shah, Imran, FB, and EM. The fact that I cast a second vote on you leaving you 3 away from being lynched, and the most likely a win for the town. With no other players hoping on. Makes me wonder why they don't want to lynch you.

 

Shah your defense is I'm too townie for you guys to kill me, plus you're scum. Is not "satisfying" my need right now.

 

side note Imran, I think you confirming Perez NA was a why to earn town points