1277 replies to this topic

[The Warrior]

 

 

Well, I believe TW, Yehom, and Lyner roles. With that, and counting myself out. That leaves 5 which could be 4 scums and one sk. it's going to be fast and little explanation, but the opposite has gotten many town lynched.

 

Vote Shah

Like your last minute Perez vote

 

Apparently, sharing suspect lists now get you revenge lynch votes. Looks like an attempt to stifle any discussion and create a wagon real quick. A mind wanders. 

 

 The fact that I cast a second vote on you leaving you 3 away from being lynched, and the most likely a win for the town. With no other players hoping on. Makes me wonder why they don't want to lynch you.

To be fair, it's probably best if this doesn't happen. We have 8 days to confirm someone as scum and I suggest we use it. An incorrect lynch ends the game.

 

I still want to hear who was protected last night. That can help us determine who may have been targeted.

[Finster Baby]

Like I said earlier. I watched EM, and he did nothing. Not sure if that's due to inactivity or not.

[KevinH]

She may not look like much, but she's got it where it counts, kid.

 
Vote Count

Shahenshah (2): Finster Baby, iSocialism,
The Warrior (0): 
Electric Mango (0): 
Yehom (0):
iSocialism (0):
Imran Ehsan (0):
ccabal86 (0):
Lyner (0):
Finster Baby (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Electric Mango, The Warrior, ccabal86, Shahenshah, Imran Ehsan, Lyner, Yehom,  

 
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.
Deadline is Thursday, March 17 at 17:00 EDT.

[KevinH]

Curse my metal body, I wasn't fast enough!


 
Vote Count

Shahenshah (2): Finster Baby, iSocialism,
The Warrior (0): 
Electric Mango (0): 
Yehom (0):
iSocialism (0):
Imran Ehsan (0):
ccabal86 (0):
Lyner (0):
Finster Baby (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Electric Mango, The Warrior, ccabal86, Shahenshah, Imran Ehsan, Lyner, Yehom,  

 
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.
Deadline is Thursday, March 17 at 17:00 EDT.

[The Warrior]

Does anyone else have any input or information? Lyner? Ccabal? Imran? Yehom?

[iSocialism]

funny how everyone is quiet.

[The Warrior]

We are running out of time and no one will contribute. If our protective roles tell us who they protected last night we might be able to figure out who the scum targeted and therefore possibly eliminate a couple people from potentially being scum candidates.

Since Yehom didn't die I think it's safe to assume that the scum did not target whomever he protected unless someone was role blocked, role stopped, etc.

What happened to ccabal?

[Finster Baby]

I think ccabal had some RL issues...

[Yehom]

I've got nothing. Sha needs to start clarifying though to prove that he is indeed a Jack of All Trades, because that is a pretty easy role to fake, especially if you have yet to use an action that was supposedly given to you. Now is the time to prove it, because basically we are starting to lose to many people to too much uncertainty. Also Imram got nothing last night?

[The Warrior]

Who did you protect last night Yehom? That can at least tell us who wasn't targeted since you didn't die.

[Imran Ehsan]

sorry guys. RL catching up with me.

 

I was waiting to hear more from ccabal and EM but both seem inactive. Remember we have to identify the scum "team". We are at a situation where we need to lynch scum every day to win. So we need to find out who is working with who and if ppl remain silent it means they dont want to play their hands by showing support for one or the other.

 

I used my action on iSocialuism last night. His quick switching of votes and him preliminariy suspecting EM first and then moving on to the Perez lynch made me suspicious. I can confirm that he indeed has the Neapolitan role.

 

For today, Shah needs to reveal what actions he did the last several nights and what results he got. There is no reason not to unless he is one of the scum. I am also suspicious of the ppl who has apparently gone inactive and i.e. ccabal and EM.

[Shahenshah]

Hi guys, I did promise I would list my actions by weekend, I will do so by my time tonight.

There are two reasons for delay, one is RL, and second is to balance the info output to ensure what all we townies still have in our bag of tricks. I suppose at this point there is no other way around this, if all the team is fine with if, which I believe to be the case, then I will go ahead.

There are two options in front of me.

Option A: With hold information in order to keep scum guessing, outcome would be I'll probably get lynched and scum perform another kill at night: worst case scenario: 2 townies short. Best case scenario: 1 townie short due to Lynch and we protect at night, we still loose.

Option B: I reveal my actions, probably not get lynched, and we take a chance at night: worst case scenario: 1 townie short at night, we loose. Best scenario: we Lynch a scum at day, protect at night, we live to fight another day.

[KevinH]

Look at the size of that thing!



 
Vote Count

Shahenshah (2): Finster Baby, iSocialism,
The Warrior (0): 
Electric Mango (0): 
Yehom (0):
iSocialism (0):
Imran Ehsan (0):
ccabal86 (0):
Lyner (0):
Finster Baby (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Electric Mango, The Warrior, ccabal86, Shahenshah, Imran Ehsan, Lyner, Yehom,  

 
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch or 3 at deadline.
Deadline is Thursday, March 17 at 17:00 EDT.

[Shahenshah]

(Hi guys, I'll be honest and if you want I can share the screenshot, but I have a job interview that has come up tommorow and I simply won't be investing time anywhere else currently. So you can lynch me or wait till tomorrow evening for my response, I'm very sorry, but it's important RL.)

I'm open to share the screenshot of the offer through PM. I'm sharing this info out of respect and courtesy, I'm not trying to buy anytime, if you all agree you can extend the deadline by same amount, I'm fine with whatever options you guys may choose).

[iSocialism]

(Hi guys, I'll be honest and if you want I can share the screenshot, but I have a job interview that has come up tommorow and I simply won't be investing time anywhere else currently. So you can lynch me or wait till tomorrow evening for my response, I'm very sorry, but it's important RL.)
I'm open to share the screenshot of the offer through PM. I'm sharing this info out of respect and courtesy, I'm not trying to buy anytime, if you all agree you can extend the deadline by same amount, I'm fine with whatever options you guys may choose).

Just leave us with your scum list and a vote that would be more than all the others right now.

[Shahenshah]

Ok, I'll make it short:

 

I'll go through:

- Lyner - townie

- Imran - townie

- iSoc - townie, as confirmed by Imran, so in light of that information, I'm moving you from suspect to townie. I still didnt like the ruse manouvre tho .

- tW - ~townie

- Yehom - Bodyguard is a key role and important role, I might have found you suspecious at different points in time in game, but right now, i'd take a risk and believe you for your role, IMO, it's worth the risk given our current situation.

- Finster - I just want more input from you man, you share stuff, your role could be what you claim it to be, but you dont participate in deduction process. You're active enough to sprinkle after the dish is cooked, but you arent in the kitchen when there is all the chaos in cooking the dish right throughout the game and it's an honest observation even you would agree with, so you're maybe scum-maybe townie.

- EM - Kevin should msg him and check so we can find a replacement. or EM needs to step up and be active.

- ccabal - you're around in other parts of the forum but you totally went missing all of a sudden, yes i stepped back too due to stuff, but i'm still ringing back here. If you are what you say you are, you can contribute so much.

 

 

 

I do sincerely intend to provide you guys with the night actions. 

 

@Yehom: You're right, it's not hard role to fake. But, initially, I didnt intend to lay out everything in front, but it seems that is what is required so I will do that. 

 

Thanks

[Yehom]

So end game is here guys. I only need Sha to confirm to me that he is indeed the Jack of All Trades. Assuming that there are indeed 3 people mafia, it is clear to me that those are: EM, ccabal and Finster.

 

TW and Isoc were confirmed by Imran to be townies. Lyner was already confirmed way before by Shamus. If Sha wants to make this game end, he can prove to me and Imran (so we have 2 people vouching) via screenshot that he is indeed the Jack of All Trades, leaving only those 3 people without actual proof of them being townies and thus most likely scum.

 

So I want to propose this, we are now at D5: we lynch EM today. He has been the most dodgy to me. Like I said about Sha before, no real information input, but the difference between Sha and EM was that EM was just not present in any debate, lurking most of the time, not even chiming in every now and then, just straight up lurking. It’s pretty safe to say that he is scum. If we are right, the game should be going on (ie we are still in the game, because we lynched the right person). Following night Imran will be protected by Lyner just as last night, I will protect Lyner to ensure both Lyner and Imran get to life to the next night. Like I said before, I’m cannon fodder, but I’m happy to be.

 

When night comes and EM is indeed mafia and lynched, Imran needs to check Finster. We need to know whether there are indeed 3 people mafia. On D6 if Finster checks out as a townie, we lynch ccabal, if Finster is mafia, we lynch him first. Night comes again and Imran needs to check the last person which is either ccabal if Finster was indeed mafia or we have won the game at that point, as long as Lyner protected Imran that night.

 

This game plan however hinges all on the fact that Sha can prove that he is indeed the Jack of All Trades. So please let him confirm first to us that he is and we can set this game plan in motion. So just to make it clear, please refrain from voting until I give the signal.
 

[iSocialism]

I don't think shah is allowed to screenshot his role. It's kind of like directly quoting the mod

[Yehom]

Kevin I'm sorry I almost broke your game. Now that I've thought about it, I understand that the screenshot thing would be kind of game breaking, so I will ask Sha not to do that. Instead I feel that the same risk needs to be taken for this plan to work. Killing one mafia is absolutely required to stay in the game. EM for me is still the best bet we have. 

 

Sha I will ask you this: do you have the ability to protect someone at night, like a docter/bodyguard? If so I want to propose the following: we proceed like I stated before, we lynch EM, if he's mafia, we get to keep playing, if not we probably lost. Imran needs to be protected at all cost, so Lyner will protect Imran, I will protect Lyner so this doesn't change. If EM was indeed mafia, only 2 will remain, but we have enough townies to win, because we will only lose one during the night, or at least we protect the ones who will win us the game. Imran will check Finster to see if he's indeed a watcher like he has suggested in the past. If he checks out as watcher, we lynch ccabal, if Finster is proven to be mafia, we lynch him immediately. Ccabal is either left as single mafia standing, or Sha is mafia as well/instead. 

 

Sha I'm going to ask to protect Lyner the night after I'm probably dead trying to protect him. 

 

PS: god I'm stupid. Sha I'm going to give you a second question: do you have the ability to serve as a cop as well? If so, we buy the town a lot of extra time. You can use that ability coming night to check ccabal. If you die that night, we know enough and everybody else gets to life to further follow the plan. If someone else dies instead, we have more info possible townies that are being doubted right now

[iSocialism]

I'm leaning towards Imran being the Mafia Godfather. We might also have a Mafia encryptor, because of the ability for mafia to talk during the day. The third mafia, with the assumption of a three mafia team and a SK. might be the ninja in which why are watchers are getting no results on some people.