Bleh... I was hoping there will be some more postings from you US folks while I was sleeping . I'll add explanation concerning Samus and his post #137 then, using simple logic.

 

So, in a previous game where Imran was a scum he mentioned killing Samus is a good choice. In our game Samus was also found dead.That means:

 

1. Imran's a scum and is using again the same move.

2. Imran's a townie and Shah is a scum trying to frame Imran.

3. Imran's a townie. Shah's also a townie, but he's foolishly thinking that only point 1. is possible.

4. Imran's a scum and Shah's a scum and the're creating confusion believing they won't get lynched because there are no solid evidences.

5. Imran and Shah can be anyone and Samus death is not connected to post #137.

 

4th option is the least probable in my opinion, as it's to risky for the scums. Rest of the options are possible and we have no evidences that will point us in any direction - therefore post #137 is useless as a proof of anything.

 

Now, if Shah is forcing it on us as a proof that Imran's a scum he's either fool or scum. So who are you Shah?

With all respects to Samus, Samus is pretty much a noob in this game. He has played only 1 game with me and in that game he got killed on N2. I think before that he played only 1 game ( i didint play that one but I guess he played well there). But he is not like some Mafia GOD that Shah is trying to claim in that he can know I am scum just by looking at some of my random posts on D1. 

 

If it was Kevin, Lyner or Kaz who made that claim it will at least be more credible. They have played plenty of games with me and know how I play normally. But just trying to get me lynched Based on Samus' clueless accusation just reeks of desperation.

ps: I know ABT is disliking this I would like to amend my earlier statement. It seems like Samus had played 2 games with me. The other one being IRON City mafia when he was actually the scum. But that was played over a year ago so I didnt remember.

I think most people try to play the same, whether scum or townie.

 

We shouldn't put much emphasis on perceived styles.

I think most people try to play the same, whether scum or townie.

 

We shouldn't put much emphasis on perceived styles.

 

This is true. The only reason past game actions is coming up is because Shah is trying to build a lynch wagon on what Samus said on D1, which was basically he thinks I am scum because apparently I played the same way in the last game where I was scum. Shah is grasping at straws to get a lynch wagon on me and hence his posts look desperate.

Wow...Lots to digest.

 

AbT, Shah, and Imran going at it.  interesting.

 

I need to read it over again in order to properly digest what's going on and lots of walls of text.

 

But I am back and thanks for undestanding.

d3mon is replacing Sister Midnight effective immediately.

I think most people try to play the same, whether scum or townie.

 

We shouldn't put much emphasis on perceived styles.

Thank you.

 

I can see why players would use people's habits from previous games and try and apply them to a current game, but in all honesty, that is the dumbest and laziest argument one can make. Every game is completely unique as well as is the way that each player probably chooses to play each game. Play styles can change or stay the same regardless of game, theme, or faction.

 

So far the only person who looks like a confirmed townie is Abt.Shah has been behaving rather oddly by jumping his gun on both Imran and Abt.But I m still not convinced that he is scum either,he just seems to be trigger happy atm.I m gonna hold my vote for now and see how things unfold.

d3mon is replacing Sister Midnight effective immediately.

Ut oh, that's not good.

d3mon is replacing Sister Midnight effective immediately.

 

 

What happened!?

 

d3mon is replacing Sister Midnight effective immediately.

 

 

What happened!?

 

I really am not enjoying Mafia and I decided to finish Teen Titans and let someone who actually enjoys the game play in my place.  No offense to anyone, it just isn't my cup of tea and it seems unfair to keep a game lover from playing.  ( @ )( @ )

I can't believe it.

 

Mafia is the most exciting part of IRON.

 

Regarding play style, it varies on outside circumstances, too.  If I happen to have time, sometimes I'll go count all the posts to prove inactivity.  If I don't have time, I don't do it.  That action is not dependent on whether I'm scum or not.

You can just click on '313 replies' in the topics list and the forums counts it for you. (of course this is not per day of course)

 

Avater is the most suspicious to me at this time. He's new ok, but he's lurking and the few posts he's made he made himself suspicious...

UNVOTE

That was really neccessary , that was a rookie ( can't u guys call me this instead of a noob as it is less insulting ) mistake and it placed me in the centre of a storm , I never meant it , it was just that I thought I would be fun but that didn't turned way . I was just trying to analyze this game as it was my first one but I think that didn't work either ( I know it's becoz the only post I made was to lynch someone ) .

Vote Count

 

Kaziocore (2): Roquentin, KevinH

Avater (1): Ali bin Turban

Imran Ehsan (1): Shahenshah

Shahenshah (1): Imran Ehsan

Ali bin Turban (0):

Chaplain of Death (0):

d3mon (0):

Finster Baby (0):

iSocialism (0):

KevinH (0):

King Hitler (0):

Lyner (0):

Mandarijn (0):

Rafay (0):

Rhizoctonia (0):
Robert2424 (0):

Roquentin (0):
TheDoom (0):

No Lynch (0):

Not voting: Avater, Chaplain of Death, d3mon, Finster Baby, iSocialism, Kaziocore, King Hitler, Lyner, Mandarijn, Rafay, Rhizoctonia, Robert2424, TheDoom

 
With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch or 5 at deadline.

Deadline is Friday, May 6th, at 9:00am CN Server Time (CST).

You can just click on '313 replies' in the topics list and the forums counts it for you. (of course this is not per day of course)

 

It's magic! You've given back to me hours of wasted time. Thanks.

 

 

 

 

 

Member name

 

Posts

 

 

 

Ali bin Turban

 

34

 

 

 

Imran Ehsan

 

30

 

 

 

KevinH

 

29

 

 

 

The Warrior

 

26

 

 

 

Chaplain of death

 

23

 

 

 

Finster Baby

 

22

 

 

 

Samus

 

18

 

 

 

Sister Midnight

 

16

 

 

 

Mandarijn

 

16

 

 

 

Shahenshah

 

15

 

 

 

Robert2424

 

14

 

 

 

Lyner

 

12

 

 

 

Rhizoctonia

 

11

 

 

 

iSocialism

 

11

 

 

 

Rafay

 

8

 

 

 

King Hitler

 

8

 

 

 

TheDoom

 

7

 

 

 

Kaziocore

 

5

 

 

 

Avater

 

4

 

 

 

Antoine Roquentin

 

4

 

 

 

d3mon

 

1

I can't believe it.

 

Mafia is the most exciting part of IRON. CyberNations

 

FTFY, I won't be here if I don't have a nation

 

 

 

 

UNVOTE

That was really neccessary , that was a rookie ( can't u guys call me this instead of a noob as it is less insulting ) mistake and it placed me in the centre of a storm , I never meant it , it was just that I thought I would be fun but that didn't turned way . I was just trying to analyze this game as it was my first one but I think that didn't work either ( I know it's becoz the only post I made was to lynch someone ) .

 

You're doing great, now tell us your real opinion on who do you think is/are suspicious and who's not and I'm pretty sure you will look less scummy

Wait did you count all the posts manually in the past, Kevin? efforts o_O

FTFY, I won't be here if I don't have a nation

pfft. You can still access our mafia forum without a nation. Mafia transcends CN.

Wait did you count all the posts manually in the past, Kevin? efforts o_O

 

I hate to admit it, but yes, I scrolled through the thread making a tally mark for each post.

 

Wait did you count all the posts manually in the past, Kevin? efforts o_O

 

I hate to admit it, but yes, I scrolled through the thread making a tally mark for each post.

 

Somehow I'm not buyin that.

Now that I've read some...

 

Imran you have me very much suspecting you. You go from lynching someone day 1 to no lynch, you make accusations on people based on previous/other mafia games.

 

Seems rather scummy to me.

 

VOTE: Imran Eshan

What? When did I ever vote no lynch? If you are gonna vote to lynch me at least give a correct reason not a false one.

 

 

Wait did you count all the posts manually in the past, Kevin? efforts o_O

 

I hate to admit it, but yes, I scrolled through the thread making a tally mark for each post.

 

Somehow I'm not buyin that.

Now that I've read some...

 

Imran you have me very much suspecting you. You go from lynching someone day 1 to no lynch, you make accusations on people based on previous/other mafia games.

 

Seems rather scummy to me.

 

VOTE: Imran Eshan

 

You people are coming one by one to take a hit at Imran. I'm got worried that I've missed something so I went again, from the beginning.

 

Finster you're repeating Avater's, Rhizo's and Shah's argument about D1 lynching. Why is D1 having so much importance to you?

 

Still you're right about talking about previous mafia games. Here's the list of post I've found:

#137 - Samus - mentioning previous games

#141 - iSoc - mentioning previous games

#256 - Imran - though he's mentioning previous games it's not actually and accusation but a cheapshot (which I hated and it was the cause of my rant some posts later when subject of previous games returned).

#279 - Shah - mentioning previous games (by referring to Samus)

#286 - Imran - mentioning previous games

#287 - Shah - mentioning previous games as a retaliation to Imran's post so it can't be counted against him.

 

But that's not enough to make Imran a scum. I won't say he's townie for sure, but now that I went through the whole topic again there are some details that may suggest that.

 

Why do I think so? Because he's natural, arrogant at times...he's not restraining himself or trying to pose as someone he's not. Maybe he's a good actor, or maybe he's just being himself because he's nothing to fear. 

- He didn't bother to go with the flow when people mass voted "no lynch" on D1.

- post #225 - a little bit of mockery and no fake sadness after Samus death.

- His general behavior and activity putting him into a spotlight.

 

Maybe Imran's a scum, maybe he's not, but at this point in my eyes he's doing town's job, because he's sparking activity. He's not latching into someone's else opinions, he's provoking discussions on his own.

 

 

 

Now moving onto other players, what I don't like is:

1. Avater's backing out of accusation. Might be a rookie scum, might be a rookie townie, but is suspicious none the less.

2. Avater, Rhizo, Shah jumping at Imran with the same arguments again and again.

3. Shah's lies (I've mentioned it already in the previous posts) and the fact he disappeared when called on them while still being active on the forums

 

more things I don't like:

4. Shah disappears, Finster appears and he's not concerned with other issues here. He's gunning straight at Imran with the same arguments as the rest.

5. I wouldn't notice that and give it no weight, but now post #226 by Finster looks like he's trying to much to look sad.

6. Finster and Shah tend to give a lot of meaning to D1 actions...so here you go, a cherry on top: post #55

 

It's all, how would you call it...a circumstantial evidence and I might be wrong...though I could cite Shah here, from his post #279 when he was lying about me:

 

"Those saying there isn't enough info, this is exactly the kind of quality of info available early on, sorry but no one is going to come out and blurt it out and lay it down for everyone."

 

Anyway I hope to see what the rest of you think about it. So far, because Shah run away when challenged about his lies:

 

Unvote

 

Vote: Shahenshah

 

Maybe that will encourage him to come back and talk with us.

Sorry. This is the last one I promise.

 

That's some pretty funny shit there.