d3mon needs to post more.

 

Vote: d3mon

Vote King Hitler

 

bad jokes are bad and you should feel bad. 

 

 

 

 

So who gets the chop..the lurkers.

The lurkers are usually NOT mafia though.

 

Mafia tend to be super active (since there are only a very few amount of them 3-5 usually), they are generally active swaying the wagons to their causes.

 

 

Some are. Many scum choose to play by being just active enough to not be "lurking" but don't actually add anything of benefit to the conversation. Others choose to play by not posting anything, and claiming some outside force causing inactivity, so that way they can avoid drawing any suspicion.

 

 

The lurkers are usually NOT mafia though. Mafia tend to be super active (since there are only a very few amount of them 3-5 usually), they are generally active swaying the wagons to their causes.

Couldn't have said it better. Killing of lurkers is the best strategy for mafia. A defenseless townie is lynched and no one can be blamed.

 

 

Killing people who are hiding and not adding to the conversation in any meaningful way and are therefore able to avoid suspicion, is a bad strategy for the town? Yes lets kill all the active people who are participating in the discussion. Definitely a good plan.

Scum will change playstyle, if the narrative is to kill lurker, they'll get active and vice versa.

 

Those hiding can be investigated, its d1.

But one day is too short a time to form a pattern of lurking.

1 real life day. If people are missing a full day in this game (a week) then that isn't by accident.

1 real life day. If people are missing a full day in this game (a week) then that isn't by accident.

Its still day 1. We know nothing. If people suspect someone for whatever there reasons be, some if them can apply the roles and see what's up. Things eventually start adding up and cases being built on solid information rather than on ad-hoc manner which scum can pass through very easily because currently the criteria seems to be let's post whatever and get post count up. You do realise white noise isn't any good.

 

No offense or pointing finger to anyone, but let's say Robert voting on bad joke and Hitler posting a bad joke have added no useful content to the game but they will clear your and some others lurk filter nonetheless.

No that makes it worse on my lurk radar. If someone posts a bunch but doesn't contribute in any meaningful way/stay away from meaningful conversation and discussion, thats the type of lurking I am looking for. 

I'm not against Lynch on D1 out of principle or something. I'm just not convinced right now about it given the reasons. If there is a solid plan and good quality content behind it, I will reconsider my vote. Bad content means bad analysis post-lynch. If you're jumping on the wagon and you get it wrong, I need to be able to sift through the content and see who was the scum on the wagon. If lurking is an argument, then it's a guilt free trip to a mislynch. I will not buy that. So spamming, lurking,lulz etc, to me are useless content upon which we will not be able to make a sound judgements post-lynch. A Lynch based on solid reasoning and arguments is good content, it allows you to find some holes the next day and makes the spinning harder.

I dont favor lynching lurkers on first day as they might be first timers and still trying to figure out game,just like me  

It's Day 1 and nobody know's nothin' (except the scum).

 

Bad jokes are good.  

It's Day 1 and nobody know's nothin' (except the scum).

 

Bad jokes are good.  

99% of your jokes are lynch worthy

Vote Count

Samus (3): iSocialism, Imran Ehsan, Roquentin

Imran Ehsan (1): Avater

Kaziocore (1): Samus

KevinH (1): Rafay

King Hitler (1): Robert2424

Lyner (1): Kaziocore

Mandarijn (1): King Hitler

Robert2424 (1): Chaplain of Death

Shahenshah (1): TheDoom

Ali bin Turban (0):

Avater (0):

Chaplain of Death (0):

Finster Baby (0):

iSocialism (0):

Rafay (0):

Rhizoctonia (0):

Roquentin (0):
Sister Midnight (0):
TheDoom (0):

No Lynch (1): Shahenshah, KevinH

Not voting: Ali bin Turban, Finster Baby, King Hitler, Lyner, Mandarijn, Rhizoctonia, Sister Midnight

 
With 19 alive, it takes 10 to lynch or 5 at deadline.
Deadline is 8:00 CST, Wednesday, April 27th.

d3mon, you're pretty active in the other game, yet only 1 post here...

 

Vote: d3mon

 

d3mon needs to post more.

 

Vote: d3mon

 

Just to note: d3mon is not a participant in this game. He is a replacement if needed. As such, neither one of these votes is valid and your previous votes still stand.

loool
 
Thats what happens when I go by Samoos' post count. <_<
 
Vote: Avater

Why the vote on avatar?

Why the vote on avatar?

 

Next lurker in the list. Roq has same/less post count but he is foreign diplo and probably doesnt visit these forums as much as Avater.

Unvote: Lyner

 

D1 is really hard because I don't know what to do and there are a lot of fluff posts everywhere lol

 

After reading the whole thread, I have a slight town read on Imran and Lyner for some reason :V

 

KevinH is being KevinH (making a lot of fluff votes and always no lynching on D1) so as much as I want to lynch KevinH for sometimes being anti-town, I guess it's too early for that.

 

In conclusion, I have no idea what to do

loool

 

Thats what happens when I go by Samoos' post count.

 

Vote: Avater

So you are unvoting Samus and voting for Avater?

 

loool

 

Thats what happens when I go by Samoos' post count.

 

Vote: Avater

So you are unvoting Samus and voting for Avater?

 

Well usually you don't need to explicitly say Unvote :V

 

 

loool

 

Thats what happens when I go by Samoos' post count.

 

Vote: Avater

So you are unvoting Samus and voting for Avater?

 

Well usually you don't need to explicitly say Unvote :V

 

It helps me make sure I didn't miss something else along the way.

Yes.

 

Unvote

 

Vote: Avater

UNVOTE

VOTE IRMAN

 

Somebody needs to pay attention more.

I dont favor lynching lurkers on first day as they might be first timers and still trying to figure out game,just like me

 

Same here.  I'm getting really paranoid that if I lurk I'll be lynched, but if I say something noob-ish I'll be lynched, it is kind of a no win if you aren't already a seasoned player.

 

I am seeing the wisdom of waiting to lynch, but not really the wisdom of lynching on the first day.  But now I'm afraid to vote no lynch.  Jeez!

@sm I would recommend asking questions to remain active then as it dose add to the conversation.

Unvote

 

Vote: No lynch

 

Yo cant manipulate targeting here - there's a list made by TW.

But maybe that list happens to favor the scum.

 

Vote: No Lynch

 

You're experienced so you surely realize that this statement can easily be reversed to tell that "scums will oppose when that list happens to put them in a bad spot", so it's really no argument.

 

Yet you keep repeating it.

Vote Count

Imran Ehsan (2): Avater, Robert2424

Samus (2): iSocialism, Roquentin

Avater (1): Imran Ehsan

Kaziocore (1): Samus

KevinH (1): Rafay

Lyner (1): Kaziocore

Robert2424 (1): Chaplain of Death

Shahenshah (1): TheDoom

Ali bin Turban (0):

Chaplain of Death (0):

Finster Baby (0):

iSocialism (0):

King Hitler (0):

Mandarijn (0):

Rafay (0):

Rhizoctonia (0):

Roquentin (0):
Sister Midnight (0):
TheDoom (0):

No Lynch (3): Shahenshah, KevinH, King Hitler

Not voting: Ali bin Turban, Finster Baby, Lyner, Mandarijn, Rhizoctonia, Sister Midnight

 
With 19 alive, it takes 10 to lynch or 5 at deadline.
Deadline is 8:00 CST, Wednesday, April 27th.