I can't resist cracking a joke here - the mafia may want to have some clean fun!

 

*Runs back to the nosebleed section*

Why on earth would the mafia have a janitor?

Why can't they have some type of informant or someone disguised as a janitor?

Okay, now I am officially confused.

I can't resist cracking a joke here - the mafia may want to have some clean fun!

 

OR they may want to mop up the game quickly

Nobody knows nothin'.

 

I'll wait until after April Fools Day to cast my serious no-lynch vote.

 

Vote: no-lynch

 

well that about does it. i'm going with Kevin, ccabal, and d3mon as the 3 mafia.

 

Proof in point. OMGUS!

Why on earth would the mafia have a janitor?

 

If you read the last mafia game setup. There was a mafia janitor role. The janitor would cover up the identity of the person killed at night.

 

 

d3mon says that it might be "flavor" but he wouldn't be surprised if he really was a janitor.

So I'm asking what he means by that.

 

VOTE COUNT

KevinH (3): Narsis, CanucksDynasty, Herodez

ccabal86 (2): Nerau, Electric Mango

d3mon (1): ccabal86

Herodez (1): d3mon

Electric Mango (1): TerrorChrist

 

No Lynch (1): KevinH

 

Not Voting (2): Preston, CaoCao

 

With 11 Alive, 6 is needed to lynch.

Edited April 5, 201115 yr by molestargazer

I am suggesting that TC is the mafia janitor.

I am suggesting that TC is the mafia janitor.

 

but why? for all we know there may not even be a janitor in the game. hence why i think you are scum and made a mistake.

I really don't understand your reasoning regarding the janitor issue d3mon, it's quite suspicious TBH...

but why? for all we know there may not even be a janitor in the game. hence why i think you are scum and made a mistake.

 

 

Since, this is part 2 of TWCWPTI... I would expect a number of roles to be similar. I might be wrong but thats the assumption that I am currently working with.

 

I am willing to listen to what TC has to say but would prefer if he said something other than "This is my first time".

Just like you, I think somebody made a mistake, but in my opinion that player is TC.

Good discussion for day 1 but I don't think making a joke about cleaning being a scum tell but I don't find it suspicious for d3mon to call him on it though. For Day 1 you have to go with what you got however.

Since, this is part 2 of TWCWPTI... I would expect a number of roles to be similar. I might be wrong but thats the assumption that I am currently working with.

Be careful about trying to guess the meta-game TOO much; trying to figure out Mole's organization of the other game led to EM getting lynched.

 

I am willing to listen to what TC has to say but would prefer if he said something other than "This is my first time".

Just like you, I think somebody made a mistake, but in my opinion that player is TC.

I'm not agreeing with your accusation of TC at the moment, but I will note that last game Tactical Evil Dan played the "It's my first time" card - and he was scum. My first game two games ago I played the "It's my first time" card to preemptively deter any suspicion, because I was scum. Playing up one's newbie status can be the perfect cover and excuse for actions that would otherwise be considered suspicious.

 

My advice to TC: we're not anti-newbie by any means. We'll gladly answer questions about how the game works, etc, and I encourage you to ask them if anything is unclear - or alternately PM mole privately. But this is a game about paranoia, analysis and accusation where every little thing one does is suspect - every statement can be picked apart for nuance. This is the reason that editing posts is not allowed: you cannot go back and fix a post that reveals something you didn't intend, or change your story after the fact. If you're new, you're new: but don't expect to be above suspicion because of it, or use it as an excuse.

 

-Preston

Since, this is part 2 of TWCWPTI... I would expect a number of roles to be similar. I might be wrong but thats the assumption that I am currently working with.

 

echoing what Preston said and with a bit more on top:

 

every game is different. doesn't matter if they have the same name or include 1 or 2 of the same roles, there are still going to be different roles involved.

 

additionally, it's not just what you said but the way you worded it. there is a difference between someone being "the janitor" and someone being "a janitor". in the first case, you are implying that there is a janitor in the game. in the second, there may or may not be a janitor in the game. the first implys having extra knowledge that players dont normally have, and furthermore that only mafia could have at this stage of the game. thus, you are mafia.

I generally prefer not to lynch newbies on D1 so as to not dissuade them from the game. But all bets are off on D2.

One free day and that's it n00bz!

Is there such a thing as noobbashing in mafia?

Is there such a thing as noobbashing in mafia?

 

Vote: noob

If you read the last mafia game setup. There was a mafia janitor role. The janitor would cover up the identity of the person killed at night.

 

 

d3mon says that it might be "flavor" but he wouldn't be surprised if he really was a janitor.

So I'm asking what he means by that.

 

What good is that? Survivors would obviously notice someone to be missing if a person is killed...?

I got to say, the argument by D3mon that this is part two, and hence it would be likely that roles are (partially) similar sounds plausible.

Too bad I didn't read part 1 :s

 

Anyhow,

 

my list of suspects is rising.

I think there will be variations in the roles.

 

I'm guessing a vigilante-type will be the butcher.

What good is that? Survivors would obviously notice someone to be missing if a person is killed...?

 

The town would know a person has died but not his role (power role, vanilla, or mafia) if the mafia janitor used his abilities. The usefulness of the role is debateable.

I think there will be variations in the roles.

 

I'm guessing a vigilante-type will be the butcher.

 

I think with so many newbies, the game will more simplified with the roles. So I expect a cop, doc, vanilla townies, and mafia.

The town would know a person has died but not his role (power role, vanilla, or mafia) if the mafia janitor used his abilities. The usefulness of the role is debateable.

 

it's very useful. if my understanding of the role is correct, it's used during the day. meaning the town doesnt get the result of the lynch.

The cop could be an immigration official.

 

The doc could be a health inspector.

The cop could be an immigration official.

 

The doc could be a health inspector.

 

again with the "the"s. for all we know there is no cop and there is no doc.