85 replies to this topic

[Northern Empire]

so you are saying you wish to hang Imran? 

[Imran Ehsan]

She is saying what result she got from her investigation of me on N0.

I investigated chaplain and got townie result.

[vgmmaster]

so you are saying you wish to hang Imran? 

As Imran mentioned, I'm just sharing my result. With our sanities unproven, it doesn't mean that they are or aren't mafia.

 

With three of us sharing our results, why don't you share yours Empire?

Also, we haven't heard from Zacch (aside from an essential non-post when the game first opened up). Would like to hear from them as well.

[Northern Empire]

ok, now i understand, 

i investigated Zacch,

the result 

Zacch is Mafia

[vgmmaster]

That's two guilty results for Zacch and is making him a potentially good lynch target for day 1 as, provided nobody has lied thus far could make clearer some of our sanities.

Present inactivity isn't doing him any favors either, but I realize it was also labor day weekend which may play into that.

[Northern Empire]

That's two guilty results for Zacch and is making him a potentially good lynch target for day 1 as, provided nobody has lied thus far could make clearer some of our sanities.

Present inactivity isn't doing him any favors either, but I realize it was also labor day weekend which may play into that.

I would agree, 

 

he seems to be the one rising to the top for lynching, 

[vgmmaster]

I want to give them a chance to respond first, ideally with their investigation results as well.

But he's not the only one I'm looking at right now.

[Imran Ehsan]

Yeah we need to know what results zacch got on N0 before deciding on who to lynch

[KevinH]

There's also the possibility that mafia may opt to not kill night 1? I'm sure that's not likely, but it raises the question of if there's a time limit for night 1 actions or if it'll last until everyone sends in an action. Kevin?

Nights will last as long as it takes for everyone to send an action.
If someone goes inactive, I'll advertise for a replacement.
Mafia may opt to no-kill, but they will have to tell me rather than miss a deadline.

[Zacch]

Yeah we need to know what results zacch got on N0 before deciding on who to lynch

 

And many other multi-quotes.....

 

So this is interesting, Chaplain and NE both claim to be cops and claim to have investigated me on night 0 with returned results of "scum" and "mafia" respectfully. Too late for clarifications, but shouldn't the results have used identical terms (i.e. both return as "scum" or both as "mafia")? It is possible that they did get the same result and are both insane. This would be pretty aggressive move by the lone goon, and they have to know that when I flip cop, they become a prime suspect. 

 

I investigated Imran on night 0 and returned the result of "Imran is Town". 

 

Yeah we need to know what results zacch got on N0 before deciding on who to lynch

 

And many other multi-quotes.....

 

So this is interesting, Chaplain and NE both claim to be cops and claim to have investigated me on night 0 with returned results of "scum" and "mafia" respectfully. Too late for clarifications, but shouldn't the results have used identical terms (i.e. both return as "scum" or both as "mafia")? It is possible that they did get the same result and are both insane. This would be pretty aggressive move by the lone goon, and they have to know that when I flip cop, they become a prime suspect. 

 

I investigated Imran on night 0 and returned the result of "Imran is Town". 

 

 

Results will be "town/mafia".

 

Vote: Chaplain.

[Zacch]

Sane Cop - Returns accurate results.

Insane Cop - Returns inaccurate results.

Paranoid Cop - Returns result of mafia-aligned for everyone.

Naïve Cop - Returns result of town-aligned for everyone.

 

What are the chances of Chaplain and NE being Insane Cop and Paranoid Cop AND both investigating me??? 

[Zacch]

Sane Cop - Returns accurate results.

Insane Cop - Returns inaccurate results.

Paranoid Cop - Returns result of mafia-aligned for everyone.

Naïve Cop - Returns result of town-aligned for everyone.

 

What are the chances of Chaplain and NE being Insane Cop and Paranoid Cop AND both investigating me??? 

 

And I could be Naive cop which would make vgm sane cop which would mean....

 

Unvote.

 

Vote: Imran

[Northern Empire]

Sane Cop - Returns accurate results.

Insane Cop - Returns inaccurate results.

Paranoid Cop - Returns result of mafia-aligned for everyone.

Naïve Cop - Returns result of town-aligned for everyone.

 

What are the chances of Chaplain and NE being Insane Cop and Paranoid Cop AND both investigating me??? 

so we would have to have a third person to investigate you to await the results, 

or i could be the sane Cop with the correct result specifically stating Mafia. .

[Zacch]

 

Sane Cop - Returns accurate results.

Insane Cop - Returns inaccurate results.

Paranoid Cop - Returns result of mafia-aligned for everyone.

Naïve Cop - Returns result of town-aligned for everyone.

 

What are the chances of Chaplain and NE being Insane Cop and Paranoid Cop AND both investigating me??? 

so we would have to have a third person to investigate you to await the results, 

or i could be the sane Cop with the correct result specifically stating Mafia. .

 

 

From my perspective (as a "not paranoid" cop), there's only two (2) possible explanations, either one (1) of you are goon or your both insane or paranoid.

 

and at the same time, myself and vgm have opposite results on the same person, one being mafia and the other town. vgm cant be naive returning a mafia result, which fits perfect with me being naive.  

[vgmmaster]

I'll have to respond more when I'm not at work and on my computer, but Zacch having a town investigation makes sense. If there was only one town result, that would essentially clear Imran as town and scum would be one of us four between myself, Zacch, empire, and chaplain.

While we don't know who the sane one is among us, I feel like the odds are that the sane cop may have had an innocent result unless they got lucky on night 0 which isn't unheard of. And with 25% odds of nailing it, that's not the worst odds.

[Chaplain of death]

 

Yeah we need to know what results zacch got on N0 before deciding on who to lynch

 

And many other multi-quotes.....

 

So this is interesting, Chaplain and NE both claim to be cops and claim to have investigated me on night 0 with returned results of "scum" and "mafia" respectfully. Too late for clarifications, but shouldn't the results have used identical terms (i.e. both return as "scum" or both as "mafia")? It is possible that they did get the same result and are both insane. This would be pretty aggressive move by the lone goon, and they have to know that when I flip cop, they become a prime suspect. 

 

I investigated Imran on night 0 and returned the result of "Imran is Town". 

 

Yeah we need to know what results zacch got on N0 before deciding on who to lynch

 

And many other multi-quotes.....

 

So this is interesting, Chaplain and NE both claim to be cops and claim to have investigated me on night 0 with returned results of "scum" and "mafia" respectfully. Too late for clarifications, but shouldn't the results have used identical terms (i.e. both return as "scum" or both as "mafia")? It is possible that they did get the same result and are both insane. This would be pretty aggressive move by the lone goon, and they have to know that when I flip cop, they become a prime suspect. 

 

I investigated Imran on night 0 and returned the result of "Imran is Town". 

 

 

Results will be "town/mafia".

 

Vote: Chaplain.

 

Apologies for being fast and loose with the exact terminology used by the mod (on 2nd look my results just say "zacch is mafia", but that seems like a very narrow line to follow for a vote when this setup is based entirely on using logic to sus out the sanity of the various cops.

Sane Cop - Returns accurate results.

Insane Cop - Returns inaccurate results.

Paranoid Cop - Returns result of mafia-aligned for everyone.

Naïve Cop - Returns result of town-aligned for everyone.

 

What are the chances of Chaplain and NE being Insane Cop and Paranoid Cop AND both investigating me??? 

So we've got 

Chaplain targeted Zacch - mafia
vgm targeted Imran - mafia
Imran targeted Chaplain - town
Northern Empire targeted Zacch - mafia
Zacch targeted Imran - town

[KevinH]

Vote Count:
Imran Ehsan (1): Zacch

Chaplain of Death (0):
Northern Empire (0):
vgmmaster (0):
Zacch (0):

Not voting: Chaplain of Death, Imran Ehsan, Northern Empire, vgmmaster

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

[Northern Empire]

Vote Count:
Imran Ehsan (1): Zacch

Chaplain of Death (0):
Northern Empire (0):
vgmmaster (0):
Zacch (0):

Not voting: Chaplain of Death, Imran Ehsan, Northern Empire, vgmmaster

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

I vote for Zacch

[vgmmaster]

 

Yeah we need to know what results zacch got on N0 before deciding on who to lynch

 

And many other multi-quotes.....

 

So this is interesting, Chaplain and NE both claim to be cops and claim to have investigated me on night 0 with returned results of "scum" and "mafia" respectfully. Too late for clarifications, but shouldn't the results have used identical terms (i.e. both return as "scum" or both as "mafia")? It is possible that they did get the same result and are both insane. This would be pretty aggressive move by the lone goon, and they have to know that when I flip cop, they become a prime suspect. 

 

I investigated Imran on night 0 and returned the result of "Imran is Town". 

 

 

 

Results will be "town/mafia".

Vote: Chaplain.

 

 

As Chaplain addressed, I wouldn't get hung up over that specifically. I know I've used multiple terms interchangeably, either in this game or in the past.

 

Sane Cop - Returns accurate results.

Insane Cop - Returns inaccurate results.

Paranoid Cop - Returns result of mafia-aligned for everyone.

Naïve Cop - Returns result of town-aligned for everyone.

 

What are the chances of Chaplain and NE being Insane Cop and Paranoid Cop AND both investigating me??? 

 

It's possible. While they can't be insane / sane, the possibility is there that they could be insane / paranoid or sane / paranoid. 

 

 

Sane Cop - Returns accurate results.

Insane Cop - Returns inaccurate results.

Paranoid Cop - Returns result of mafia-aligned for everyone.

Naïve Cop - Returns result of town-aligned for everyone.

 

What are the chances of Chaplain and NE being Insane Cop and Paranoid Cop AND both investigating me??? 

 

And I could be Naive cop which would make vgm sane cop which would mean....

 

Unvote.

 

Vote: Imran

 

 

I could also be insane and you sane (or vice versa). Or myself paranoid and you naïve. Or some combination thereof. 

 

Of note, Imran was the third to reveal their investigation results, but the first to reveal a town result. With them being one of two town results and the fact they haven't pinged my scum radar as of yet, I'm more willing to believe they are a cop over mafia at the present time. And until you posted, I was already doubting my own sanity and I feel I'm either paranoid or insane (not sure which as of yet). 

[vgmmaster]

 

 

snip

Even with fake results from the goon hopefully we can start to lock in on what our individual modifiers are. 

I investigated Zacch and received a scum result.

 

 

Not pointing the finger at Chaplain here, but quoting for posterity. Noteworthy that Chaplain was the first to reveal his investigation without being prompted. Also one of two to investigate Zacch.

 

so you are saying you wish to hang Imran? 

 

In response to my investigation of Imran coming up guilty. I never once claimed to want to lynch them at the time.

 

ok, now i understand, 

i investigated Zacch,

the result 

Zacch is Mafia

 

Imran clarifies my post, then Empire reveals as the second person to investigate Zacch and took being prompted to reveal their investigation Not suspicious in itself, but as someone who got a guilty result herself on someone else, unless one of the three of us is sane with an accurate result, I'm leaning to think either Chaplain or Empire is scum with this early link to each other. 

 

 

That's two guilty results for Zacch and is making him a potentially good lynch target for day 1 as, provided nobody has lied thus far could make clearer some of our sanities.

Present inactivity isn't doing him any favors either, but I realize it was also labor day weekend which may play into that.

I would agree, 

 

he seems to be the one rising to the top for lynching, 

 

Just like that, Empire agreeing with me and instead of seeming to want to shoot for a lynch on Imran switches quickly to Zacch. While points for Zacch were being made at the time, I'm noticing a trend that Empire doesn't seem to be thinking for themselves much as of right now. 

 

 

Vote Count:
Imran Ehsan (1): Zacch

Chaplain of Death (0):
Northern Empire (0):
vgmmaster (0):
Zacch (0):

Not voting: Chaplain of Death, Imran Ehsan, Northern Empire, vgmmaster

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

I vote for Zacch

 

And a vote without any reasoning. 

I'll admit to not knowing Empire's playstyle (or really anyone's here except for Kevin's), so maybe this is normal for him. But as of right now Empire is the scummiest in my eyes. And with that said:

VOTE: Northern Empire