MOD: Can we get a vote count? Is EM lynched or not? I don't see a rule that says once a player has been lynched that a person cannot unvote.

Well our list of suspects should be narrowed down quite a bit.

 

I believe CD, Kevin, Kaziocore, and ccabal86 are townies. I'm pretty sure Preston is as well and I know I am.

 

 

If I die, good luck town. Otherwise I suggest we unvote me and vote for Tactical Evil Dan or AKCPLUTO.

If I die, good luck town. Otherwise I suggest we unvote me and vote for Tactical Evil Dan or AKCPLUTO.

Can you provide references/posts/quotes to back up your looking at TED and AKCPLUTO?

 

-Preston

I thought Kaziocore was a townie until I had him notified that I am a townie and then he was trying to push the Player X disclosure.

 

I'm sorry but where did I ask who Player X is?

I'm sorry but where did I ask who Player X is?

Prompted by this and KevinH's statement, I went back to look over your posts, which I'm quoting below. Unless I missed one, you only posted these two:

 

Well you said you only saw three people that moved at N1.

Kasabian, EM and Person X

 

Kasabian being a powerless goon (which means he killed Nerau),

only EM or Person X could be some kind of a roleblocker.

You mean Player X messaged you or you just read all his text so you could come

to the conclusion that he is scum?

 

Anyway I am more inclined to believe that EM is mafia.

As CD have explained before, it was weird that ccabal would just roleclaim but

regardless if he's scum or not, you're still more likely to scum.

With no more logical explanation that can be thought of, EM

could only say "Well just have to wait and see what happens next then."

then possibly to get more info on who to nk next, asked who Player X is.

This is very suspicious.

 

Right now I'm just waiting for AKCPLUTO to speak on this matter.

I dont see you overtly asking who PlayerX is in here, though I could see how your second post would be taken that way.

Rereading KevinH's post, it seems to me he more meant that his vote on you was an "in case of death, suspect Kaziocore" plan - i.e. because he used his power to PM his towniness to you.

So yeah... without going back further, I dont see much else really suspicious here now.

 

While looking this up though, I noticed AKCPLUTO hasn't posted since 2/28. Has anyone seen him watching the thread?

 

-Preston

I dont see you overtly asking who PlayerX is in here, though I could see how your second post would be taken that way.

Rereading KevinH's post, it seems to me he more meant that his vote on you was an "in case of death, suspect Kaziocore" plan - i.e. because he used his power to PM his towniness to you.

So yeah... without going back further, I dont see much else really suspicious here now.

 

It was really a matter of style. CD had asked if anybody else had heard from Player X and Kaziocore didn't respond. If it were me, I would have probably said something like "I heard but I'm not saying..."

 

If a scum got the confirmed townie message, optimal play would be to keep quiet and then night-kill. The town won't lynch a known townie and it's in the scum's beswt interest to keep all the townies suspecting each other.

 

Anyway, my role confirms my towniness but nothing more. A night-kill on me now would waste a chance to get a more powerful role. Now that I've been "outed," CD is probably a bit more safe, too.

Can you provide references/posts/quotes to back up your looking at TED and AKCPLUTO?

 

-Preston

 

It's not that they did anything, it's just that everyone else is townie IMO. They are the only two that are left.

MOD: Can we get a vote count? Is EM lynched or not? I don't see a rule that says once a player has been lynched that a person cannot unvote.

 

7. A lynch requires a majority (50% rounded down + 1) vote. You can also No Lynch, by using Vote: No Lynch.

...

8. After someone has been lynched, discussion may continue until I get to the thread and close it.

I think a lynch is a lynch.

It was really a matter of style. CD had asked if anybody else had heard from Player X and Kaziocore didn't respond. If it were me, I would have probably said something like "I heard but I'm not saying..."

 

Can you quote where CD has asked that question?

Can you quote where CD has asked that question?

 

Not that hard to find ...

 

@Everyone - has Player X tried contacting you at all? Wondering if this is a one-shot ability.

Uh, sorry for my absence folks. The RL monster seems unable to get go of me right now.

 

Vote counts coming up shortly.

Unvotes do not count after a lynch has been reached. Sorry!

 

VOTE COUNT

Electric Mango (5): CanucksDynasty, ccabal86, AKCPLUTO, Preston, Tactical Evil Dan

ccabal86 (1): Electric Mango

Kaziocore (1): KevinH

 

Not Voting (1): Kaziocore

 

With 8 alive, 5 is needed to lynch.

 

This time, it was the turn of Electric Mango to be dragged, struggling, to the side of the pool where his head is held under until he stops struggling. Unfortunately, you find nothing but an empty packet of chocolate-covered coffee beans in EM's pocket.

 

Electric Mango, INSOMNIAC, has been lynched.

It is now NIGHT THREE. Actions to me by Tuesday 8th.

Good luck town.

Day dawns once more on the pool. And, once more, there's a body floating in it.

 

You drag the body out of the pool to discover it's the body of KevinH - quite well-known and well-loved around the community.

Shame.

 

KevinH, FRIENDLY NEIGHBOUR, has been killed.

It is now DAY FOUR. Deadline for today is Wednesday 23rd.*

 

*An extra day so today can be purely for pancake-eating if you so wish.

This doesn't bode well for us. Needless to say, I still haven't found out anything.

 

If we mislynch today, it's GG

ALIVE:

ccabal86

Kaziocore

CanucksDynasty

Preston

AKCPLUTO

KevinH

Tactical Evil Dan

 

DEAD:

Nerau, Whistle-Blowing Lifeguard (One-Use Roleblocker), killed Night One.

Kasabian, Mafia Goon, lynched Day Two.

Chaoshawk, Pool Cleaner (One-Use Vigilante), Killed Night Two.

Electric Mango, Insomniac, lynched Day Three.

 

 

---------------------------

 

 

D1 Vote Count

Electric Mango (3): Tactical Evil Dan, CanucksDynasty, Preston

Preston (1): Nerau

AKCPLUTO (1): Kaziocore

 

No-Lynch (5): KevinH, ccabal86, AKCPLUTO, Chaoshawk, Electric Mango

 

Not Voting (1): Kasabian

 

 

D2 Vote Count

Kasabian (7): Electric Mango, Kaziocore, ccabal86, Preston, KevinH, CanucksDynasty, Tactical Evil Dan

Electric Mango (1): Kasabian

 

Not Voting (2): AKCPLUTO, Chaoshawk

 

 

D3 Vote Count

Electric Mango (5): CanucksDynasty, ccabal86, AKCPLUTO, Preston, Tactical Evil Dan

ccabal86 (1): Electric Mango

Kaziocore (1): KevinH

 

Not Voting (1): Kaziocore

Sorry...the first page wasn't updated...

Damn. I knew I'd forgotten something. -M

 

ALIVE:

ccabal86

Kaziocore

CanucksDynasty

Preston

AKCPLUTO

Tactical Evil Dan

 

DEAD:

Nerau, Whistle-Blowing Lifeguard (One-Use Roleblocker), killed Night One.

Kasabian, Mafia Goon, lynched Day Two.

Chaoshawk, Pool Cleaner (One-Use Vigilante), Killed Night Two.

Electric Mango, Insomniac, lynched Day Three.

KevinH

Edited March 8, 201115 yr by molestargazer

My suspects are...

 

AKCPLUTO - cuz he didn't vote for Kasabian and bandwagoned vote on EM.

Tactical Evil Dan - cuz his vote on Kasabian wasn't required and his vote for EM was the hammer (even though he stated he didn't think he was mafia).

 

 

 

Kaziocore - I believe he is townie cuz he placed the 2nd vote on Kasabian.

 

 

IF Preston and ccabal86 are mafia....well played.

bah!

Bummer - Kevin gone now?

 

My vote immediately goes to Kaziocore for not voting yesterday. vote: Kaziocore.

Bummer - Kevin gone now?

 

My vote immediately goes to Kaziocore for not voting yesterday. vote: Kaziocore.

 

 

But he voted for Kasabian who turned out to be mafia whereas you did not vote at all.

You voted for EM who turned out to be townie whereas Kaziocore did not vote for EM.

Allright, here is who I don't think are mafia:

 

Preston, CD.

 

Who's left? Kazio, TED, and AKC. CD makes a good point about Kazio, but I wouldn't give him a free pass. So I say we vote for either AKC or TED.

 

I also believe everyone who hasn't roleclaimed yet should do so now.

I want to hear AKCPLUTO and TED roleclaim first. In one of his previous posts...TED said he was a plain jane.

Able to post during lunch; may be able to check but not post after this until the evening.

 

It seem EM really was Insomniac - which verifies that negative roles DO exist.

I find mafia's choice of killing KevinH strange - he'd basically been confirmed town already, and his ability to mod-confirm himself as town was therefore somewhat redundant - why was he worth taking out?

Not that it matters much anymore, but KevinH used his last night action last night to confirm his towniness to me.

 

So we're down to lynch-or-lose. CD has stated some good suspects:

AKCPLUTO - cuz he didn't vote for Kasabian and bandwagoned vote on EM.

Tactical Evil Dan - cuz his vote on Kasabian wasn't required and his vote for EM was the hammer (even though he stated he didn't think he was mafia).

AKCPLUTO has been fairly inactive after his initial bandwagon on EM on day 3. Has he been observed checking into the thread but not posting?

TED - I already stated my reasons to be suspicious of him, but there's nothing terribly strong there.

 

In addition, CD's own very strong targetting of EM ever since day 2 is quite suspect... especially in that he persisted in doing so once the premises for his initial analysis (limited number of town roles, etc) began to fall. Further, given that we're actually on Day 4 instead of game over means that Kasabian's scum death was a REAL scum death and not a post-mortem mafia alter. It could still have been a deliberate sacrifice, however. With that said, it HAS been confirmed that CD had some sort of detect-movement ability, and the security guard profile is unlikely to have been given to mafia.

 

Ccabal and Kaziocore - nothing's jumping out to my memory about these two at present, other than KevinH stating that he gave a townie hello to Kaziocore on night 2.

 

I'll read through more past posts when I get home to develop more of an opinion. My current thought is that all else being equal, I will probably vote AKCPLUTO.

 

-Preston

I want to hear AKCPLUTO and TED roleclaim first. In one of his previous posts...TED said he was a plain jane.

 

That would be because I am a plane Jane townie. I have no role to claim beyond that, "negative" (if that's the term to use for EM's insomnia) or otherwise.